Part 4 of 10

“Again,” a cruel stepmother ordered as a shovel struck inches from her stepdaughter’s bare fingers; then an elderly judge recognized the torn green cuff.

39 min read · November 17, 2026

“I can prove I cared for it,” I said.

“That is not the same thing.”

“I know what she taught me.”

Marcia leaned closer.

“Then you should know better than to make a spectacle in a judging tent.”

The volunteer with the sash looked toward Judith.

“Mrs. Hastings?”

Judith’s gaze remained fixed on the root ball.

“I have not finished examining the entry.”

“Judging hasn’t officially started.”

“Then no one will object to my looking.”

Marcia’s face tightened.

She placed one white-gloved hand against the pot.

“I’m sorry, but I cannot allow anyone to handle the plant.”

Judith’s eyes lifted.

“Why not?”

“It has just been transported.”

“Exactly.”

“It needs to settle.”

“It needs to be judged.”

“After the other entries are arranged.”

“No.”

A few people exchanged glances.

Marcia lowered her voice.

“Please don’t embarrass yourself.”

Judith stepped closer to the pot.

“I am ninety years old, Mrs. Crawford. I stopped worrying about embarrassment sometime before you were born.”

The tent seemed to draw inward around us.

Outside, children laughed near the cider stand. Inside, every eye fixed on the rose.

Judith reached for the edge of the pot.

Marcia quickly moved it away.

The wheels scraped across the floor.

“No,” Marcia said.

Judith’s cane came down.

“Put it back.”

Marcia’s white gloves trembled.

“I am the entrant.”

“And I am the head judge.”

“My name is on the card.”

“Your name is not the same as the truth.”

A hush fell over the nearest tables.

My father stepped forward.

“Judith, this is inappropriate.”

She looked at him.

“Then tell me, Dean. Did Lillian grow this rose?”

His face emptied.

Marcia turned toward him.

“Dean.”

He rubbed his thumb over the patron badge pinned to his jacket.

The same motion.

The same silence.

Judith watched him for a long moment.

Then her attention returned to the plant.

Beneath the burlap and damp soil, a thin glint of copper showed near the edge of the root ball.

It was there and gone when the pot shifted.

Judith saw it.

I knew she had because her eyes stopped moving.

“What is that?” she asked.

Marcia’s hand tightened on the pot.

“Nothing.”

Judith leaned closer.

“Move your hand.”

“It is part of the root support.”

“Move it.”

Marcia looked toward the crowd.

“Someone please get security. This woman is interfering with my entry.”

The volunteer hesitated.

Judith did not.

She placed one gloved hand on the pot and spoke so clearly that people at the far end of the tent turned to listen.

“Everyone step back.”

Marcia reached for the rose.

Judith’s cane blocked her.

“Do not move that plant,” Judith said.

For the first time, Marcia looked afraid.

Chapter 3

For the first time, Marcia looked afraid.

Then three men in green patron jackets moved between Judith and the plant.

“Let’s all take a breath,” one of them said.

His name was Walter Bell. I recognized him from the photograph in the show program. He chaired the county horticultural board, and Marcia had served him lemonade in our garden less than an hour earlier.

Judith did not move her cane.

“I asked to inspect an entry.”

“And you may,” Walter said. “During final judging.”

“I am inspecting it now.”

Marcia pressed a hand to her chest.

“She nearly knocked it over.”

“You moved it,” I said.

Walter glanced at my dirty clothes, then at Marcia’s blue dress.

“Who is this young lady?”

“My stepdaughter,” Marcia said before I could answer. “She is having a difficult day.”

“I’m Lillian Crawford’s daughter.”

“Yes, Rose,” my father said. “They understand.”

“No, they don’t.”

Judith pointed toward the root ball.

“There is metal beneath that soil.”

Walter bent slightly but did not touch the pot.

“Probably nursery wire.”

“It has a copper edge.”

“Then you can examine it with the other finalists.”

Marcia’s fear eased.

“Thank you, Walter.”

Judith looked from him to the other patrons.

“If that plant is moved, altered, watered, trimmed, repotted, or touched before I inspect it, I will disqualify it.”

Walter’s smile faded.

“That seems excessive.”

“It is considerably less excessive than entering stolen work.”

The crowd stirred.

Marcia turned to my father.

“Dean, tell them.”

He stood just outside the circle, still rubbing his patron badge.

She held out her white-gloved hand.

“Tell them who bred this rose.”

My father looked at me.

I silently begged him not to do it.

He had already failed me in the garden. He had let Marcia call me hired help. He had watched her crush Mother’s marker.

But there was still a difference between silence and a lie.

“Dean?” Walter prompted.

My father cleared his throat.

“Marcia bred and cared for the rose.”

The tent seemed to tilt.

Somewhere behind us, a tray fell. Metal clattered against the floor, but no one turned.

Judith’s face became very still.

“Say that again,” she said.

My father’s fingers closed over his badge.

“The rose is Marcia’s entry. She bred it and cared for it.”

“You saw her cross the parent plants?”

“I saw her work in the garden.”

“When?”

“That is a ridiculous question,” Marcia snapped.

Judith ignored her.

Up next