Part 5 of 10

As the trailer carried away my trembling 14-year-old dog, the mayoral candidate grabbed my wrist—then a woman saw the snowflake whistle and ran screaming.

41 min read · November 16, 2026

“I’m asking a serious question.”

Derek moved closer to her.

“You were invited to Coldwater to support local agriculture. I would think you’d be careful about creating a scene that could damage the community’s confidence in its elected officials.”

Alice looked past him at the campaign sign.

“Is that a warning?”

“It’s advice.”

“You’re advising me to ignore what happened because you’re running for re-election?”

“I’m advising you not to let an emotional child manipulate an official investigation.”

I looked at him.

“I didn’t manipulate anybody.”

Derek turned sharply.

“Stay out of this.”

Alice’s eyes flicked toward me.

“Sam has been trying to explain what happened since the sale began.”

“He has been resisting a necessary decision.”

“You called his grandfather’s dog junk.”

“I said the dog was no longer useful.”

“You threw the boy’s whistle into a cattle trough.”

Derek’s expression hardened.

“That was not relevant to the sale.”

“It was relevant to your conduct.”

The crowd fell quiet.

Derek looked from face to face, searching for the people who usually laughed when he spoke. A few supporters lowered their eyes. One campaign volunteer began gathering paper cups from a table, though there was nowhere for him to take them.

Derek pointed toward me.

“Sam is upset because I refused to let him keep an animal he cannot care for.”

“I can care for him,” I said.

“You save your lunch money to feed him.”

“I do.”

“You sleep in the mudroom with him.”

“Sometimes.”

“That is not proper care.”

“Grandpa taught me.”

“Your grandfather is dead.”

The words landed in the open space between us.

Alice’s face changed.

Not dramatically.

Just enough that I saw something hard settle behind her eyes.

“You have mentioned Howard Fletcher several times,” she said.

Derek stopped.

“What about him?”

“You say he abandoned the dog.”

“He did not maintain the property.”

“Did he leave a written instruction?”

“He left papers.”

“Then produce them.”

“I already told you. They are at home.”

“And yet you brought the dog to a public auction.”

Derek’s jaw worked.

“I brought the dog to a licensed sale because it needed a better home.”

“You arranged the sale before today.”

“That is how auctions work.”

“No,” Alice said. “That is how private transfers work. An auction requires an honest offering, a clear seller, and a record of the property being sold.”

Marvin looked down at the ledger.

Derek’s eyes flashed toward him.

“Tell her the entry is valid.”

Marvin swallowed.

“The entry is in the book.”

“That wasn’t my question,” Alice said.

Marvin looked at the crowd.

The people who had been willing to laugh a few minutes earlier were no longer laughing.

“I was told the mayor had authority,” he said.

“By whom?”

Marvin did not answer.

Derek’s voice cut across the silence.

“By me.”

“That is not proof,” Alice said.

“It is proof enough for this town.”

The words came out too quickly.

Derek seemed to realize what he had said, but he did not take them back.

I looked at the people around us.

Some of them had voted for him.

Some had put his signs in their yards.

Now they stood with their plates in their hands, watching him claim that his word was stronger than every document, every witness, and every question.

Derek reached toward my neck.

“Give me the whistle.”

I stepped back.

“No.”

“You will give it to me.”

“It’s mine.”

“It belongs with the rest of Howard’s property.”

“You said it was junk.”

“I said you have no right to parade it around.”

Alice held out her hand.

“Sam, may I see it?”

I looked at her.

The whistle was muddy, but I could still feel the tiny running snowflake beneath my thumb.

Derek turned on her.

“That is family property.”

“You just told me it was a personal souvenir your stepfather never intended Sam to have.”

“It was.”

“Then why are you trying to take it from him?”

“Because he is a child.”

“Children can own property.”

Derek gave an impatient shrug.

“Not when they are being used to create a public disturbance.”

Alice kept her hand extended.

“Sam?”

My fingers tightened around the whistle.

I did not know her.

She was a stranger who had arrived beside Derek’s supporters, wearing a silver snowflake and speaking in a voice that made grown men stop moving.

But she had told Derek to release me.

She had asked where Patch was going.

She had looked at the trailer as if the dog inside mattered.

Slowly, I placed the whistle in her palm.

Alice closed her fingers around it.

For several seconds, she said nothing.

Her thumb brushed the carved snowflake.

Then she turned the whistle over.

The color drained from her face.

She looked at the mouthpiece.

At the three uneven cuts.

At the repaired split in the wood.

Her breathing changed.

Not much.

Just one sharp breath, as if someone had struck her.

Derek noticed.

“What is it?”

Alice didn’t answer.

She held the whistle closer to the light.

The crowd leaned forward.

Derek reached for it.

She pulled it back.

“Where did Howard get this?”

“I told you,” Derek said. “He carved it.”

“Where?”

“He made it himself.”

“How many?”

“What?”

“How many whistles did he make with this exact repair?”

Derek’s eyes narrowed.

“Howard carved dozens of whistles.”

“Then you should know that a carving is not the same as a repair.”

She touched the three uneven cuts with the tip of one finger.

Up next