Part 8 of 9

“Dead people don’t get presents.” My stepmother locked me outside in freezing snow after burning my mother’s photograph—then an old woman recognized the face and screamed a name.

36 min read · November 16, 2026

“She was being manipulative.”

“She was seven years old.”

“She is not innocent.”

“No child deserves this,” Bernice said.

Pastor Goodwin removed the Christmas service notes from the pulpit.

He folded them once and set them on the front pew.

Then he lifted the framed photograph and placed it where his notes had been.

Mama’s face looked down at all of us.

“I will not preach from this pulpit tonight,” he said, “until we tell the truth about what happened to Lucy.”

Colleen backed toward the door.

“I’m leaving.”

“No,” Pastor Goodwin said.

“I am going home.”

“You are not taking Lucy.”

“She is my stepdaughter.”

“And you are not leaving with her.”

Colleen reached for the door handle.

Pastor Goodwin held up his phone.

“The police are on their way.”

Her hand fell.

The children in the choir loft had been taken into the fellowship room, but several families remained in the sanctuary. The grown-ups looked different now. Their faces were no longer soft with sympathy for Colleen.

They looked ashamed.

The woman in the green sweater came to me.

“I’m sorry, Lucy.”

I looked at her.

“You heard me.”

“I did.”

“Why didn’t you open the door?”

She lowered her eyes.

“I believed Colleen when she said you were having an episode.”

“Why?”

“Because she sounded certain.”

Bernice looked at her.

“Certainty is not proof.”

“I know that now,” the woman said.

One by one, other people began speaking.

A man near the aisle said Colleen had asked him two weeks earlier whether he knew anyone who bought old jewelry.

An elderly woman said she had seen a blue sweater in the back of Colleen’s car.

Another volunteer remembered a silver locket listed in a photograph on the Angel Tree family form.

Colleen shook her head harder and harder.

“You’re all making this up.”

Roy closed the notebook.

“The charity account is short three hundred and eighty dollars.”

Everyone turned toward him.

“What?” Pastor Goodwin asked.

“I checked it this morning. We received cash donations for coats and gifts. Some of it is missing.”

Colleen’s breathing changed.

“No.”

Roy looked at her.

“Only two people had access to the cash box.”

“Are you accusing me?”

“I’m saying the money is missing.”

Pastor Goodwin’s expression became grim.

“Roy, bring the account records and the donation log to the office.”

“I will.”

“And call the police.”

“I already did.”

A car door slammed outside.

Colleen looked toward the windows.

The fear in her face was different from the fear she had performed for the church.

This fear was real.

She turned to me.

“Lucy, you have to tell them I took care of you.”

I held tighter to Bernice.

“You locked me outside.”

“I was trying to teach you a lesson.”

“You burned Mama’s picture.”

“I was upset.”

“You sold her things.”

“I needed money.”

“You said she abandoned me.”

Colleen’s mouth trembled.

“I was the one who stayed.”

Bernice lowered herself beside me.

“Lucy,” she said gently, “you do not have to protect her.”

I looked at Mama’s photograph on the pulpit.

The paper star was small and damaged. But it was still there.

“She didn’t stay for me,” I said.

Colleen flinched.

Bernice took my hand.

“She stayed because she wanted to own what was left.”

The sanctuary doors opened.

Two police officers came inside, followed by Pastor Goodwin’s assistant. Snow clung to the officers’ shoulders.

Colleen immediately lifted her chin.

“I am Lucy’s legal guardian.”

One officer, a woman with short gray hair, looked at me first.

“Are you Lucy Yates?”

I nodded.

“Are you hurt?”

“My arm hurts.”

Bernice gently pulled back the sleeve of my sweater. Red marks were already rising where Colleen had held me.

The officer’s expression changed.

“Who did that?”

I looked at Colleen.

“She did.”

Colleen shook her head.

“I barely touched her.”

The officer turned to her partner.

“Please speak with the pastor and the treasurer.”

Then she crouched in front of me.

“My name is Officer Ramirez. I need to ask you some questions. You can answer in front of Bernice if you want.”

I nodded.

Bernice stayed beside me.

Officer Ramirez asked about the photograph, the frame, the burn barrel, and the locked door. I told her everything. My voice shook at first, but it grew steadier with each answer.

I told her about the blue sweater.

The jewelry box.

The silver locket.

The porcelain angel.

I told her how Colleen touched the red brooch whenever she lied.

Officer Ramirez glanced toward Colleen.

Colleen had stopped touching it.

When I finished, Officer Ramirez asked, “Do you feel safe going home with Colleen tonight?”

“No.”

The answer came before I could be afraid of it.

Colleen’s face collapsed.

“Lucy.”

“No,” I said again.

Bernice squeezed my hand.

Officer Ramirez stood.

“Lucy will not be returning home with you tonight.”

“You can’t take my child.”

“We are not taking your child,” Officer Ramirez said. “We are making sure she is safe while the proper authorities investigate.”

“I have rights.”

“So does she.”

The second officer returned with Pastor Goodwin and Roy. He carried the church’s donation notebook and a folder of records.

Officer Ramirez spoke with them quietly.

Colleen stood alone near the sanctuary doors.

No one went to her.

Up next