Part 3 of 9

“Don’t move.” My son locked his eighty-year-old father outside in sleet, snapped his carved walking stick, then a grieving guest recognized one name...

38 min read · November 16, 2026

Nadine reached for her again.

This time, Kay backed away.

Donovan pointed toward the hallway.

“Dad can sit in the laundry room until dessert.”

Judith’s eyes narrowed.

“The laundry room?”

“There’s a chair. It’s warm and quiet.”

“I don’t need quiet,” I said.

“You need to cooperate.”

His voice dropped on the last word.

The warning was for me alone.

I knew what he wanted.

He wanted me to bow my head.

He wanted me to tell everyone he was right.

That I had wandered out.

That I had broken the stick.

That the cold had made me confused.

I had rescued him from his own behavior so many times that he no longer considered it a favor.

He considered it my duty.

I looked at Kay.

She was frightened.

Not of me.

Of her father.

So I did what I had always done.

I tried to make the room safe by making myself smaller.

“All right,” I said.

Kay grabbed my sleeve.

“No, Grandpa.”

“It’s fine.”

“It isn’t.”

“I know.”

Donovan led me toward the laundry room.

He did not touch me in front of Judith.

He kept one hand hovering near my elbow, performing concern.

When we passed through the doorway, his fingers clamped down.

Hard.

“Sit,” he whispered.

The laundry-room chair was a folding metal chair beside the dryer.

A basket of clean towels sat on its seat.

Donovan dropped the towels on the floor.

“There.”

I looked back toward the dining room.

Judith was still holding the broken piece.

Kay stood near her coat.

Nadine stared at the floor.

“You told people I’m unstable,” I said quietly.

Donovan’s jaw moved.

“You make it necessary.”

“Necessary?”

“You don’t know when to stop talking.”

“I haven’t said anything.”

“Exactly. Keep doing that.”

He stepped into the dining room and raised his voice.

“Dad will be more comfortable here.”

Nobody answered.

He took his seat at the head of the table.

“Please,” he said. “Sit down. We’ve all had a stressful few minutes.”

Chairs moved slowly.

A few guests sat because they did not know what else to do.

Judith remained standing.

Nadine removed the silver dome from the turkey. Steam rose into the room.

The smell turned my stomach.

Donovan began carving.

His hand was steady.

“Judith,” he said, “I hope this doesn’t affect our conversation about the regional position.”

Nadine flinched.

Even I could not believe he had said it.

Judith looked at him as if she had never seen him before.

“This is not the time.”

“Of course not. I only mean that family caregiving can be complicated.”

“Is that what you call this?”

He set one perfect slice of turkey on a platter.

“I have spent years managing my father’s decline.”

I almost laughed.

Not because it was funny.

Because it was so polished.

So complete.

He had built an entire history in which his cruelty became sacrifice.

Nadine carried the platter around the table.

When she passed the laundry-room door, she stopped.

Her eyes met mine.

“Would you like a plate?” she asked.

Before I could answer, Donovan said, “Later.”

Nadine stood there for a moment.

Then she moved on.

Kay did not sit.

She slipped toward her winter coat and put her hand inside the pocket.

I remembered the smaller piece of the stick.

She drew it out just enough to look at it.

The broken wood was darker near the top.

More names wound around it.

She turned it slowly.

Then her eyes narrowed.

Tiny marks had been carved beside Andrew’s name.

Not a number.

Dates.

Kay looked toward me.

I shook my head once.

Donovan was watching.

She pushed the wood back into her pocket.

“Kay,” he said. “What do you have?”

“Nothing.”

“Bring me your coat.”

“No.”

He put down the carving knife.

“Now.”

Judith stepped between them.

“She said she has nothing.”

Donovan smiled tightly.

“She’s upset. I’m trying to calm her.”

“By taking her coat?”

“She hid more of Dad’s broken stick.”

Judith held out her hand to Kay.

“May I see it?”

Kay looked at me first.

I nodded.

She took out the second piece and placed it in Judith’s palm.

Judith set both pieces together on the table.

The split did not fit cleanly, but Andrew’s name became whole.

ANDREW “RABBIT” HASTINGS. 6.

Below it was the busted star.

And beneath that were the dates.

Judith bent closer.

Her fingertip moved along them.

“Those aren’t baseball seasons,” she said.

“No,” I answered.

There were too many.

Some were only days apart.

Others followed in long rows.

March 3.

March 4.

March 6.

March 7.

Then dates from years after Andrew had left Little League.

Judith looked at Donovan.

“You said your father barely knew my son.”

“He did barely know him.”

She turned to me.

I wished the sleet would swallow the whole house.

I wished I were still outside.

I wished Andrew’s name had remained safe beneath my hand.

Donovan lifted another slice of turkey as if the question had already been settled.

“I’ll arrange a ride for Dad after dessert,” he said. “It’s best if we get him home before he becomes more agitated.”

I said nothing.

Judith watched me accept the lie.

She watched me sit on a metal chair beside the dryer while my family ate Thanksgiving dinner twenty feet away.

Then she tapped the dates beneath her son’s worn name.

“Herbert,” she said, “why do these dates go years beyond baseball?”

Chapter 3

Judith’s finger rested on the first date.

Up next