Part 5 of 10

“Don’t move.” My stepmother pinned me against Dad’s telescope while my stepsister held its shattered eyepiece—until a hidden brass chart made the judge seize it.

40 min read · November 17, 2026

Another nodded sympathetically at Janice.

I felt something inside me tear.

She was using his death as decoration.

She was turning the worst year of my life into a speech she had not written, beside a telescope she had not built, wearing goggles she had never earned.

Bernice looked toward me.

“I know some people have found it difficult to accept this project,” she said. “Sometimes grief can make it hard to remember who did what.”

Janice lowered her eyes.

A soft, wounded expression spread across her face.

Bernice continued.

“But science depends on facts, not feelings.”

That line had not been in my notes.

I looked at her.

She had added it herself.

The crowd grew still.

Bernice took one step toward me.

“My stepsister has insisted that she built this instrument. She has made accusations, disrupted the presentation, and damaged equipment that belongs to me.”

A few people turned to look at the broken eyepiece.

Janice gave a small, sorrowful shake of her head.

Bernice’s voice grew stronger.

“I have tried to be patient because she is an orphan.”

The word struck me harder than Janice’s arm had.

Orphan.

It traveled through the gym and settled over me.

I was sixteen years old. I knew what the word meant.

But Janice had never allowed it to become the name of my life.

Not until that moment.

Not until she needed strangers to see me as a child without a family, a girl whose memories could be dismissed because the person who could defend them was gone.

Bernice looked at the judges.

“She has been confused since her father’s death. We have tried to help her, but she does not want anyone else to receive credit for his work.”

My fingers curled against the telescope.

Janice had promised me that nobody would touch Dad’s observatory.

She had promised his notebooks would remain safe.

She had thrown away my sketches and called me confused when I asked where they were.

Now she stood behind Bernice and let her call me an orphan in front of the entire state competition.

The old judge with the blue folder looked at Janice.

“Did you approve that statement?”

Janice blinked.

“I’m sorry?”

“Did you approve your daughter’s remarks about Zoe?”

Janice’s expression became pained.

“Doctor, Bernice is speaking from the heart.”

“Is she?”

“She has worked very hard.”

“That was not my question.”

Janice glanced at the crowd.

“Zoe has been struggling since her father died. We have tried to be compassionate.”

My face burned.

There it was again.

Confused.

Unstable.

A grieving girl.

Janice never had to prove I was wrong. She only had to make people wonder whether I was reliable.

Bernice turned back to the judges.

“I would like to demonstrate the telescope’s intended use.”

Radcliffe held up the brass chart.

“Before you do that, answer a question.”

Bernice’s confidence faltered.

“About the chart?”

“About the lens.”

Janice stepped forward.

“Dr. Radcliffe, you have already questioned her extensively.”

“I have asked her to identify the instrument’s purpose.”

“She has done that.”

“No. She has repeated terms from a notebook.”

Janice’s smile thinned.

“You seem unusually determined to discredit a seventeen-year-old student.”

“I am determined to understand the work.”

The judge with the blue folder looked between them.

“Dr. Radcliffe, what specifically do you need to know?”

Radcliffe held the chart against his palm.

“Which star was this lens tuned to reveal?”

Bernice stared at him.

The question sounded simple.

It was not.

I could see that she did not understand why.

Her eyes moved to the false notebook. She turned the pages quickly, searching for an answer Janice had not given her.

Janice leaned close to her.

“Say Sirius,” she whispered.

Bernice straightened.

“The lens was tuned for Sirius.”

Radcliffe’s face remained still.

“Why Sirius?”

“It is one of the brightest stars in the night sky.”

“Why tune a telescope for a bright star?”

“To make it easier to observe.”

“You described this as a deep-sky instrument.”

“It can observe many objects.”

“That was not my question.”

Bernice’s fingers tightened around the note cards.

Radcliffe looked at the notebook.

“Your documentation says the instrument was designed to collect faint light from distant objects. Sirius is not faint.”

“I said it could observe Sirius.”

“You said the lens was tuned for Sirius.”

“It was one of the objects I tested.”

“Was it the object this lens was specifically made to find?”

Bernice’s mouth opened.

Janice gave her a sharp look.

Bernice changed direction.

“The telescope was designed for the North Star.”

A sound went through the crowd.

Not quite laughter.

Not quite disbelief.

Radcliffe looked at her.

“Polaris?”

“Yes.”

“Why?”

“Because it is important for navigation.”

“Is that why this lens was hand-ground?”

Bernice looked at the notebook.

“It is a precise star.”

“Polaris is visible to the naked eye.”

“Yes.”

“Then why did your project describe the instrument as a deep-sky telescope?”

“Because it can do both.”

“Can it?”

Bernice’s face flushed.

I could hear the next answer before she gave it.

“Of course.”

Radcliffe lowered the brass chart.

“What is the focal adjustment required to observe Polaris?”

Bernice hesitated.

“The same adjustment used for any star.”

“No. The focal adjustment depends on the optical path and the distance between the objective lens and the eyepiece.”

Up next