Part 1 of 10

“Don’t,” the captain snapped as my 13-year-old body crashed into metal bleachers. Then an old coach saw one white stitch on Dad’s torn wristband—and locked the doors.

39 min read · November 16, 2026

Chapter 2

STORY CONTINUES

“Lock the doors,” the old coach shouted.

His voice cut through the gym.

The referee stopped with one hand raised. The crowd quieted in uneven waves. Players turned toward the sideline. Even the pep band faltered, one trumpet holding a note too long before dying away.

Coach Marlow stared at him.

“What are you doing, Talbot?”

The old coach did not look at him. He kept the torn wristband closed in his fist.

“Preserve the recording,” he said.

My heart gave one hard beat.

“What recording?” Coach Marlow demanded.

Edwin Talbot finally turned toward him. Up close, he looked older than I had first thought. His silver hair was thin at the temples. A deep scar ran from the corner of his mouth toward his jaw. His cane leaned against the scorer’s table, forgotten.

“The athletics camera,” he said. “The one by the far sideline.”

Coach Marlow glanced toward it.

The red light still blinked.

“The camera records every game,” he said.

“It was recording before this game began.”

His eyes moved to Cheryl.

“And it recorded the introductions.”

Cheryl’s face changed.

Only slightly.

But I saw it.

Her mouth parted. Her shoulders drew back. For the first time since she had grabbed my wrist, she looked less like the captain and more like the girl who had realized she might not control the next sentence.

Coach Marlow frowned.

“You’re accusing my player based on a camera you haven’t even seen?”

“I’m saying nobody erases or overwrites that file until an official reviews it.”

Edwin’s hand remained closed around the band.

The tournament referee walked toward us. He was a broad man with a gray mustache and a whistle hanging from his neck.

“What’s going on?”

Edwin pointed at the camera.

“There was a disputed physical confrontation during introductions. That camera has the angle. I want the footage preserved before the game continues.”

The referee looked at Cheryl, then at me.

Cheryl folded her arms.

“She attacked me,” she said. “Now their coach is trying to get involved because Holly’s upset about being benched.”

Edwin’s eyes hardened.

“I am involved because I saw what was torn.”

He opened his hand.

The two pieces of blue fabric lay across his palm.

The gym had grown so quiet that I could hear the ventilation system above us.

He turned the band over.

“This is mine.”

Cheryl gave a short, disbelieving laugh.

“No, it isn’t.”

“I gave it to Lewis McCall.”

The name moved through the crowd.

Dad had been gone almost two years, but people still said his name differently when they remembered him. Some said it softly. Some said it with the excitement of a favorite play. To most of the gym, Lewis McCall was a former star, a state champion, and Cheryl’s father.

To me, he was the man who had fallen asleep in a chair with his hand wrapped around mine.

Edwin looked down at the faded blue fabric.

“After the 1998 state title,” he said. “Lewis wore this through the entire tournament. I gave it to him after the final buzzer.”

Cheryl shook her head.

“That’s not proof. Dad had dozens of things from basketball.”

“This has number fourteen woven into the inside seam.”

Edwin lifted one torn half.

The number was difficult to see beneath the frayed threads, but there it was.

Fourteen.

My number.

Dad’s number.

The one I wore because he had told me, years ago, that it looked right on me.

Cheryl’s eyes went to the jersey across my chest.

“No,” she said.

Edwin looked at me.

“Did Lewis give you this band?”

My fingers curled against my scraped palm.

The honest answer rose immediately.

Yes.

But saying it out loud felt like stepping onto a court with no shoes, no teammates, and no place to hide.

Cheryl watched me.

Her expression did not ask a question. It demanded a choice.

I could tell the truth and make her look like a liar.

Or I could stay quiet and let her keep the story she had built.

I thought about Dad in the kitchen, his hands trembling as he pushed a needle through the old fabric. I thought about his face when he asked me to promise.

Do not tell Cheryl why I chose you.

Not because I love her less.

Because she is hurting.

Because she needs to believe there is still a place for her.

I had been twelve years old, sitting at the kitchen table with my knees knocking the cabinet beneath it.

I had promised.

So I said nothing.

Edwin studied my face.

“You don’t have to protect anyone from the truth,” he said.

My throat tightened.

Cheryl stepped forward.

“She stole it,” she said. “She took it from Dad’s room after he died.”

“That is not what I asked,” Edwin replied.

“She lies when she wants attention.”

“Cheryl,” Coach Marlow warned.

She turned toward him, her voice rising.

“You saw her refuse to give it back. You saw her hiding it. She attacked me because I asked where she got it.”

“I saw Holly on the floor,” Coach Marlow said. “I did not see the beginning.”

Up next