Part 3 of 10

“Don’t,” the captain snapped as my 13-year-old body crashed into metal bleachers. Then an old coach saw one white stitch on Dad’s torn wristband—and locked the doors.

39 min read · November 16, 2026

Toward me.

She mouthed, See?

As if the basket had proven something.

Our team was still ahead, but the rhythm had changed. Cheryl began forcing shots. Pearl missed a pass she would normally catch. Coach Marlow shouted instructions that Cheryl ignored.

Whenever the camera’s red light appeared in her peripheral vision, she glanced toward it.

The game clock moved.

The lead shrank.

At halftime, we were tied.

In the locker room, no one spoke to me.

The athletic trainer cleaned the scrape on my hand while I sat at the end of the bench. The antiseptic stung so badly that my eyes watered.

“Sorry,” she said.

“I’m fine.”

She looked at the torn band in my lap.

“That was your dad’s?”

I nodded.

“Can it be fixed?”

“I don’t know.”

She reached for one piece, but I closed my hand around it.

“Not yet.”

She withdrew her fingers.

Across the room, Cheryl stood before the mirror, fixing her hair. Her reflection met mine.

“You’re enjoying this,” she said.

I blinked.

“What?”

“All these people staring at me. Edwin making a scene. Coach treating me like I’m the problem.”

“You shoved me.”

Her hand stopped at her ponytail.

“Keep saying that. Maybe if you repeat it enough, someone will believe you.”

“You tore Dad’s band.”

“You stole Dad’s band.”

“He gave it to me.”

The words came out before I could stop them.

The room went still.

Cheryl turned slowly.

“Say that again.”

I held the two pieces close to my chest.

“He gave it to me.”

“Why?”

I said nothing.

Her face changed from anger to something sharper.

“Why did he give it to you?”

The promise pressed against my ribs.

I could feel the hospital room around me—the pale walls, the quiet machine, Dad’s thin fingers closing over mine.

Do not tell her.

Cheryl came closer.

“Why you?”

I looked down.

Her laugh was small and empty.

“Because you were the sick one?”

I flinched.

“Because he felt sorry for you?”

“Stop.”

“Because he knew you’d never be good enough to earn anything yourself?”

“Stop.”

She leaned close.

“Or because he loved you more?”

The athletic trainer looked up.

“Cheryl.”

Cheryl ignored her.

“Tell them,” she said. “Tell everyone why Dad picked you.”

I pressed my lips together.

She smiled when I stayed silent.

“That’s what I thought.”

The second half began before the tournament official arrived.

Coach Marlow had no choice, or so he said. The tournament clock could not be held indefinitely. The athletics department had confirmed that the camera file was preserved, but the official assigned to review it was delayed by another game on the opposite court.

“We’ll deal with it after the semifinal,” Coach Marlow told the referee.

Edwin disagreed from across the court.

“No. Before the final decision.”

The referee warned him that another interruption could result in a technical foul.

Edwin nodded.

“Then give me one.”

His team’s assistant coach grabbed his arm.

“Edwin.”

He pulled free.

“I will not let a child be punished because adults are in a hurry.”

His team lost possession while he argued. Our crowd cheered when Cheryl stole the ball and scored.

She ran past the bench, breathing hard.

“See?” she whispered. “They still want me.”

I looked at the scoreboard.

Our lead was four.

She returned to the court and took the next shot without passing. It hit the rim.

Pearl grabbed the rebound.

Instead of shooting, she looked toward the bench.

Her eyes met mine.

Then Cheryl shouted her name.

Pearl passed the ball.

Cheryl scored.

She turned to the spectators and raised both arms. The crowd answered with a roar.

The scouts wrote something on their pads.

Cheryl came back to the bench during the timeout, flushed and shining with sweat.

She held out her hand.

“Give me the band.”

“No.”

“You heard Edwin. It belongs to him.”

“He said he gave it to Dad.”

“And Dad gave it to me.”

“He didn’t.”

Her fingers snapped toward my lap.

I pulled the band away.

Cheryl looked around to make sure people were watching.

Then she lifted her voice.

“She’s still refusing to return our father’s property.”

Coach Marlow turned.

“Holly, hand it over until this is settled.”

“It’s mine.”

“How do you know?”

“Because Dad gave it to me.”

The coach stared at me.

Cheryl’s eyes gleamed.

“Then explain why.”

I couldn’t.

My silence spread through the bench.

Pearl lowered her head.

One of our forwards moved away from me as if secrets were contagious.

Cheryl reached down and took the torn band from my hand.

I tried to stop her, but she pulled back.

“Cheryl!”

She held it above her head.

The blue fabric dangled in two ruined pieces.

“Look,” she announced to the team. “This is what Holly does. She takes something that belongs to all of us and hides behind it.”

“Give it back,” I said.

“Dad’s things aren’t toys for a charity case.”

The words struck the bench.

The crowd heard this time.

Several people turned.

Cheryl lifted the band higher, showing the torn seam and the crooked white stitch.

Up next