Part 2 of 10

“Don’t you dare open that!” My stepmother threw Dad’s toolbox into an icy river; I lunged after it, until a fisherman saw Dad’s screw in my bleeding palm.

40 min read · November 16, 2026

Yvonne lunged.

Howard moved faster.

He caught the bundle against his chest and stood.

Mr. Bowman reached for him.

“Give that to Mrs. Lambert.”

Howard turned his shoulder.

“You can ask. You cannot take.”

Yvonne came through the gate so quickly that Mr. Cooper grabbed her arm.

“Let go of me!”

“You’re not touching that boy or the box.”

“I am his legal guardian!”

The words came out before she could smooth them.

Howard heard them.

“So you say.”

Yvonne’s face changed again.

She turned toward the neighbors, but there was no softness left to put on.

“Judge Waverly is stealing from a grieving widow,” she said. “He has frightened a child and is now filling his head with fantasies.”

Howard placed the wrapped bundle beneath his coat.

Then he took the photograph from the toolbox.

The plastic sleeve had clouded with river water, but the picture inside was still visible.

He held it up.

I saw the basement wall.

The loose brick.

The narrow white envelope in Yvonne’s hand.

She was crouched beside the wall, exactly as I remembered.

Her head was turned toward the basement stairs.

Toward me.

The photograph showed only part of her face, but I knew it.

I knew the blue cardigan she wore that night.

I knew the silver bracelet on her wrist.

My breath stopped.

“That’s her,” I said.

Yvonne went pale.

Howard looked at me.

“Are you sure?”

“I saw her.”

“You saw her in the basement?”

Yvonne jerked against Mr. Cooper’s grip.

“Caleb, don’t.”

I flinched at the sound of my name.

Howard’s voice remained steady.

“Don’t what?”

Yvonne looked at the neighbors.

“Don’t let a stranger manipulate him. He’s confused. He hasn’t slept. He watched his father die.”

“My dad didn’t die in front of me,” I said.

She turned on me.

“Enough.”

The word made my fingers curl.

Howard noticed.

He reached into his coat and took out a clean handkerchief. He wrapped it around my palm without asking.

The cut from the screw had opened farther. Blood had run down between my fingers.

“Hold that there,” he told me.

I did.

“What’s the envelope?” he asked.

I stared at the photograph.

“It was behind the brick.”

“What was inside?”

“I don’t know.”

Yvonne shook her head.

“There was no envelope.”

The photograph said there was.

My memory said there was.

And the way Yvonne had thrown the toolbox into the river said there was something worse than an old bill waiting inside it.

Howard looked down at the oilcloth bundle.

“Let’s find out what Edgar protected.”

He carried the toolbox and its contents to the broad stone ledge beside the river.

Mr. Cooper opened the gate, and I followed.

Yvonne shouted after me.

“Caleb, stay away from that man!”

I kept walking.

Not because I trusted Howard yet.

Because he was the first adult who had looked at me instead of looking around me.

Howard unwrapped the bundle.

Inside was a sealed plastic envelope, two sheets of paper, and a small black-and-white photograph.

The papers were damp at the edges, but the handwriting remained dark.

Howard carefully unfolded the first sheet.

At the top, in Dad’s handwriting, were the words:

To Whom It May Concern.

My knees weakened.

I knew that handwriting.

The tall E in Edgar.

The way he crossed his t’s too far to the right.

The way the last letter in his name leaned upward, as though it wanted to leave the page.

Howard read silently for several seconds.

Then he looked at me.

“This is a guardian letter.”

“What does that mean?”

“It means your father wrote down who he wanted responsible for you if he could not be.”

I looked toward Yvonne.

She had stopped fighting Mr. Cooper.

Her arms hung at her sides.

Howard continued reading.

“I, Edgar James McCall, being of sound mind and acting voluntarily, name my sister, Angela Rose McCall, as guardian of my minor son, Caleb Aaron McCall…”

The river rushed behind him.

The van engine idled near the gate.

Nobody spoke.

Howard read the rest more slowly.

Dad wrote that Angela knew me, loved me, and had agreed to care for me. He wrote that she should be contacted immediately if anything happened to him.

At the bottom was his signature.

Edgar James McCall.

Below it was the date.

Six days before he went to the hospital.

I stared at the signature until the letters blurred.

“He chose Aunt Angela?”

Howard lowered the page.

“Yes.”

“Yvonne said he didn’t.”

“I can see that.”

“He said she refused.”

Howard’s expression hardened.

“Your father’s letter says otherwise.”

Yvonne’s voice came from behind us.

“That is forged.”

Howard turned.

“You recognize the handwriting?”

“I recognize my husband’s handwriting. I also recognize desperation when I see it.”

“Desperation is what made you throw the box into the river?”

Her mouth opened.

Nothing came out.

Howard placed the guardian letter on the stone, weighted with the photograph sleeve.

Then he picked up the black-and-white picture.

It showed a basement workbench.

Dad’s motion-activated camera sat on a shelf near the furnace. I remembered it. He had installed it after tools started disappearing.

The photograph had captured the basement from above.

Yvonne stood near the loose brick.

Up next