Part 6 of 10

“Don’t you dare open that!” My stepmother threw Dad’s toolbox into an icy river; I lunged after it, until a fisherman saw Dad’s screw in my bleeding palm.

40 min read · November 16, 2026

He was broad and red-haired, with a name badge that read HOLLIS.

“Judge,” he said.

“Deputy Hollis.”

“Mrs. Lambert called.”

“I assumed she would.”

“She says you took the boy.”

“I brought him here because he was being removed from the state without confirmed authority.”

Deputy Hollis looked at me.

“What do you want to do, son?”

My mouth went dry.

I wanted to say I wanted my father.

I wanted to say I wanted to go home.

I wanted to say I wanted an adult to make the decision so I would not be blamed for it.

Instead, I looked at Howard.

He nodded once.

“I want to stay with Judge Waverly until Aunt Angela comes.”

Deputy Hollis studied my face.

“Are you hurt?”

“My hand is cut.”

Howard showed him the handkerchief.

“And your wrist?”

I shook my head.

“Yvonne grabbed me.”

Deputy Hollis looked toward Howard.

“She says the judge abducted him.”

Howard handed him the original letter.

“She also says this is forged.”

Deputy Hollis read the first lines.

His expression changed.

“Where did you get this?”

“False bottom of Edgar McCall’s toolbox.”

“The toolbox that went into the river?”

“Yes.”

Deputy Hollis looked at me.

“Your father?”

I nodded.

“And this photograph?”

“Same place.”

Howard gave him the plastic sleeve.

Deputy Hollis stared at the picture for several seconds.

Then he handed everything back.

“Clerk’s office is open. We can get this entered and call emergency services.”

“Thank you,” Howard said.

We had barely crossed the lobby when the courthouse doors flew open.

Yvonne stood inside.

Russell Bowman was behind her.

So were Mrs. Talley, Mr. Cooper, and three other neighbors from the road.

The ranch driver remained near the entrance, his yellow folder clutched against his chest.

Yvonne had changed clothes.

The black funeral dress was gone.

She wore a cream-colored coat, a silk scarf, and a small gold cross at her throat.

Her hair had been brushed smooth.

She looked like a woman who had come to address a misunderstanding.

Not a woman who had thrown a toolbox into a freezing river.

“There he is,” she cried.

Her voice trembled.

“Caleb, thank God.”

She hurried toward me.

I stepped behind Howard.

The movement was small.

Everyone saw it.

Yvonne stopped with one hand pressed to her lips.

Mrs. Talley made a quiet sound.

“I was afraid you’d been frightened into leaving with him,” Yvonne said.

Howard’s shoulders went rigid.

“Do not perform for me.”

“I am not performing.”

She turned to Deputy Hollis.

“This retired judge took advantage of my grief. He found my stepson beside the river, filled his head with accusations, and brought him here without permission.”

“I found him locked outside your gate,” Howard said.

“He ran from the house.”

“He was trying to retrieve his father’s toolbox.”

“He has an obsession with broken things.”

Yvonne looked at the neighbors.

“He has not been himself since Edgar died. He becomes confused and aggressive. I had arranged a safe placement for him.”

Russell lifted the yellow folder.

“A temporary residential program.”

“Four hours away,” Howard said.

“For his protection.”

“You misspelled his name.”

Russell looked down.

The folder seemed suddenly too bright in his hands.

Yvonne reached for it.

“Mr. Bowman has worked with troubled children for years.”

“I have worked with intake paperwork,” Russell said.

Her fingers froze.

The courthouse clerk came through a side door.

She was a small woman with silver hair and reading glasses on a chain.

“What is happening?”

Deputy Hollis handed her the guardian letter.

“We have a minor child, a disputed placement, and a letter naming a different guardian.”

The clerk read the page.

“Angela McCall?”

“Edgar’s sister,” Howard said. “She is on her way.”

Yvonne stepped forward.

“Angela has no legal claim.”

“Neither do you,” Howard said.

“I am the surviving spouse.”

“That does not make you the named guardian.”

The clerk looked at me.

“What is your name?”

“Caleb Aaron McCall.”

She glanced at the yellow folder.

“Not McColl.”

“No, ma’am.”

“Caleb, do you understand why you’re here?”

I looked at the floor.

The courthouse tiles were white and gray, arranged in squares.

There were twelve between my shoes and the clerk’s desk.

I counted them twice.

Yvonne moved closer.

“He is overwhelmed. He cannot make decisions.”

“I can answer,” I said.

Yvonne’s hand settled on my shoulder.

Her fingers were light.

That made it worse.

“He will repeat whatever Judge Waverly has taught him,” she told the clerk. “He is suggestible. He is grieving. He is not stable enough to speak for himself.”

Howard removed her hand from my shoulder.

He did it gently, but firmly.

“Do not put your hands on him.”

Yvonne’s eyes filled.

The neighbors watched her.

She turned to them.

“Do you see what I have endured?”

Mrs. Talley lowered her gaze.

Mr. Cooper did not.

The clerk looked from Yvonne to me.

“Caleb, whom do you want to go with?”

The question entered me like cold water.

I knew the answer.

I wanted Aunt Angela.

I wanted Dad’s house.

I wanted Howard.

I wanted the person my father had written down.

But saying one name felt like hurting everyone else.

My mouth opened.

Nothing came out.

Yvonne squeezed my shoulder.

Up next