Part 5 of 12

“Get behind me.” My stepfather shoved a boy toward black water, tore his glove, and sank his walnut keepsake—until the warden recognized its knot.

48 min read · November 16, 2026

The crowd had gathered around the youth board. The flags snapped overhead. The open fishing hole yawned behind us, black and still.

Leonard waited with the lure in his hand.

He looked exhausted.

His bare fingers were swollen and red, and one of the medical volunteers had wrapped a towel around his forearm.

But when I reached him, he stood straighter.

He placed the red-and-silver lure back in the box.

“Jake,” he said, loud enough for everyone to hear, “your grandfather didn’t just tie this knot.”

The crowd leaned closer.

“He tied it for every child who came here without much.”

Aaron shook his head.

Leonard continued.

“He made sure the first Bellweather derby had safe holes, loaner rods, and a youth board. He told us the lake had room for everybody.”

He looked at the banner above us.

“And he made one request.”

“What request?” someone asked.

Leonard held my gaze.

“That no child should ever be sent home from this ice because his equipment was too old, too cheap, or too plain.”

A woman near the back began to cry.

Aaron’s voice cut through the silence.

“That’s enough.”

Leonard turned to him.

“No. It isn’t.”

The old warden lifted his walking stick and pointed toward the banner.

“Take down the name of every man who claimed this derby was theirs.”

The official looked startled.

Aaron stepped forward.

“Do not touch that banner.”

“Why?” Leonard asked. “Because Willard’s name isn’t on it?”

Aaron’s face flushed.

“It was organized by the Bellweather Business Association.”

“After Willard built it.”

“After he made a few lures.”

“After he gave this town its promise.”

Aaron turned toward Bradford.

“Mr. Sutton, you can see what this is. Leonard is using a grieving child to settle an old personal score.”

Bradford’s gaze moved from Aaron to the box.

“I can see that emotions are high.”

Aaron seized on the words.

“Exactly.”

Bradford looked at me.

“Jake, perhaps it would be best if you went home.”

The ice seemed to tilt beneath my feet.

Home.

With Aaron.

With the box he had tried to destroy.

Mom looked at Bradford, then at me.

Leonard’s hand closed around his walking stick.

Aaron’s shoulders relaxed.

He thought he had won.

I lowered my eyes to the walnut box.

The wood was scratched.

The lid was crooked.

But inside, Grandpa’s lures were still tied with the same tiny double loop.

I touched the red-and-silver one.

And for the first time that morning, I wondered if Grandpa had left me more than a way to catch fish.

I wondered what else Leonard knew.

Then Leonard bent toward me and whispered, “Your grandfather never told his family why he started this derby.”

He looked past me at Bradford Sutton.

“Not even when he had every reason to.”

Bradford’s face changed.

Only slightly.

A flicker.

A shadow.

His hand moved to the pale scar across his palm.

Leonard saw it.

So did I.

Then Bradford looked away.

Aaron reached for my shoulder.

“Come on,” he said.

Leonard stepped between us again.

“Not yet.”

The crowd held its breath.

Leonard looked at the lure, then at Bradford.

“Not until this town remembers who gave it the lake.”

Chapter 3

“Not until this town remembers who gave it the lake.”

Leonard’s voice carried across the ice.

Aaron stood three feet away, one hand still reaching toward me.

He looked at Leonard.

Then at Bradford.

Then at the crowd.

The charming man was gone.

What remained was a tight mouth, a red face, and eyes that promised punishment later.

“You’re making a serious mistake,” Aaron said.

Leonard held up the red-and-silver lure.

“No. I made the mistake of waiting this long.”

He turned toward the people gathered around the youth board.

“Look closely,” he said. “This is not an ordinary knot.”

A man near the banner squinted. “Looks like a knot to me.”

“It’s a double loop,” Leonard said. “Small enough to hold under pressure. Tight enough to keep from slipping. Willard tied it sideways, like a figure eight.”

He turned the lure so the crowd could see.

“Every lure he made had the same knot.”

I touched the edge of the box.

“Grandpa said it made them easier to repair.”

Leonard looked at me.

“Your grandfather never told you the real reason?”

I shook my head.

“He didn’t talk much about himself.”

“That was Willard.”

Leonard’s expression softened.

“He could spend three hours teaching a child how to read thin ice, but ask him what he’d done with his own life, and he’d wave you off.”

Aaron gave a cold laugh.

“Because there wasn’t much to tell.”

Leonard turned on him.

“You keep speaking about a dead man as if he can’t answer you.”

“He can’t.”

A hush moved through the crowd.

Aaron seemed to realize he had gone too far.

He looked toward Bradford.

“Mr. Sutton, I’m sorry. This is exactly what I meant. The boy’s family has been caught up in these old stories for years. I was trying to bring him back to reality.”

Bradford didn’t respond.

His eyes were still on the lure.

The red-and-silver paint had faded with age, but a thin stripe of silver remained beneath the water droplets. The line curled around the hook in that tiny sideways figure eight.

Up next