Part 5 of 10

“Get off the stage.” My mother-in-law shoved my eight-month pregnant body beside a splintered manger—then panicked when hidden carved letters surfaced beneath it.

40 min read · November 16, 2026

“Everyone remembers Christmas,” she said. “It was a busy season.”

Maribel shook her head.

“No. I remember that night.”

Pastor Ralph slowly lowered the manger.

“Maribel, come forward.”

Darlene tightened her grip on Victor.

“You do not need to involve yourself in this.”

Maribel stepped into the aisle.

“I was working the overnight shift,” she said. “There had been freezing rain. Warren came in just after midnight with a woman in labor.”

Darlene’s face lost all color.

Victor looked at her.

“Mom?”

She released his sleeve.

Maribel reached the front pew and rested both palms on it.

“Warren brought the woman into the delivery room. He told me to prepare the instruments. He had already called ahead from the road.”

Ralph’s eyes moved to the carving.

“Was the baby’s name recorded?”

Maribel looked at Victor.

“Yes.”

Victor’s voice was barely audible.

“What was the woman’s name?”

Darlene stepped forward.

“Maribel is confused.”

“I am not confused.”

“You delivered dozens of babies.”

“Hundreds.”

“Then you cannot possibly remember one delivery from thirty years ago.”

Maribel’s expression softened.

“I remember the babies whose mothers stayed.”

Darlene flinched.

Victor saw it.

“Mom. What is she talking about?”

Darlene turned toward him.

“She is trying to hurt me.”

“Why?”

“Because Warren hated me.”

Ralph’s voice was quiet.

“Warren did not hate you.”

“You were his friend. You always took his side.”

“I took the side of the truth.”

Darlene faced the congregation.

“This is exactly what I warned everyone about. Teresa brought that broken thing here to create a spectacle, and now people are dragging an old woman into it because they want to destroy me.”

I looked at Maribel.

“Do you remember the mother’s name?”

Darlene’s eyes snapped toward me.

“Do not ask her that.”

The words rang through the sanctuary.

Maribel turned to me.

“Yes. Her name was Darlene McCall.”

Victor made a sound behind me, something between a word and a breath.

Darlene closed her eyes. When she opened them, she faced the congregation.

“At the time, I was very young. I was frightened. I was in labor. People forget what fear can do to a person.”

Victor took one step toward her.

“You told me you were thirty-two.”

“I was thirty-two.”

“You told me you had me at home.”

“I was confused about the details.”

“You told me Warren arrived afterward.”

“He did arrive.”

“After what?”

“After the delivery.”

Maribel shook her head.

“No.”

Darlene turned on her.

“You were not in the room.”

“I was at the clinic.”

“You were an aide.”

“I was the nurse who stayed with you.”

“You were not the doctor.”

“I did not say I was. Warren delivered the baby. I assisted him. You were exhausted, but the baby was healthy.”

Victor stared at her.

“You’re saying Warren delivered me?”

“I am saying Warren delivered a baby boy on December twenty-third, 1993. He wrote the name Victor McCall on the clinic log before he left the room.”

Ralph looked down at the manger.

The date beside Victor’s name seemed darker than the others.

“Why did he write the name?” Victor asked.

Maribel looked at Darlene.

“Because your mother gave it to him.”

The silence pressed against my ears.

Darlene’s lips parted.

“Maribel was never fond of me.”

“I brought you blankets,” Maribel said. “I held your hand while Warren worked. I found you clean clothes. I did not need to be fond of you.”

“You always judged me.”

“I watched you hold your baby.”

Darlene looked away.

“You held him for less than a minute,” Maribel continued. “You asked whether the clinic could keep him. Whether there was another family. You said you had made a mistake and could not take him home.”

“That is a lie.”

“You signed the release form.”

“I was sick.”

“You were frightened.”

“I was in pain.”

“I know.”

“You don’t know anything about me.”

“I know you walked out before dawn.”

Darlene stepped toward her.

“Stop.”

“You left the baby in the nursery. Warren found him crying when he returned from speaking with the administrator.”

Darlene’s expression twisted.

“He was not crying.”

Maribel looked at the carved name.

“He was.”

Victor turned to his mother.

“You left me?”

“That is not what happened.”

“You left me at the clinic?”

“I came back.”

“You told me I was born at home.”

“I was going to come back.”

“You told me you held me all night.”

“I was young.”

“You told me you raised me from the moment I was born.”

“I did raise you.”

His voice broke.

“Not from the moment I was born.”

Darlene reached toward him.

Victor stepped back.

The movement struck her harder than any accusation.

“Victor,” she whispered.

He shook his head.

“Don’t.”

“I was scared.”

“Don’t.”

“I had no money. No family. Your father was gone.”

“You said Dad abandoned us.”

“He did.”

“You said Warren helped you because you were alone.”

“He did help me.”

“After you left me?”

Darlene looked around the sanctuary. The board members sat frozen. The children had been gathered near the curtain. Judith Conway held my script against her stomach.

“Maribel,” Darlene said, “you are remembering this incorrectly.”

“I am remembering the paper,” Maribel replied. “The original clinic log is in the county archives. Warren also wrote a note.”

He lifted the manger slightly.

Up next