Part 1 of 9

“Give it back.” A stuttering child is trapped behind a locked prop-room door after her grandmother’s puppet is torn—why does the janitor recognize its blue stitches?

39 min read · November 16, 2026

Chapter 2

STORY CONTINUES

The doorknob rattled again.

“Mae?” Tamara called. “Open this door.”

I looked at Clarence.

One hand covered the puppet beneath his jacket. The other rested on the lock.

“Why did you lock it?” I whispered.

“So they can’t take this.”

Outside, Tamara tapped her silver badge against the door.

Tap.

Tap.

Tap.

“Clarence, open up.”

He didn’t move.

“Did you hear me?”

“Yes,” he called.

“Then unlock the door.”

Clarence looked at me, then at the puppet.

“If I open it,” he said, “they’ll throw her grandmother’s work away.”

The words struck me harder than I expected.

Her grandmother’s work.

Not a broken prop.

Work.

I pressed my back against the shelves. Old paint cans crowded one side of the room. Folding risers leaned against the other. Dust floated through the light beneath the door.

Tamara rattled the knob again.

“Mae, you are not in trouble if you come out right now.”

I almost laughed.

My throat hurt too much.

I had been called disruptive, difficult, out of control. Now Tamara wanted me to believe a locked door had changed everything.

Clarence took a key ring from his pocket.

“You have the key?”

He nodded.

“Then why don’t you let us out?”

“Because I want them to think the lock is stuck.”

He walked to a narrow worktable and pulled a small metal sewing kit from beneath a stack of programs.

“You carry that everywhere?” I asked.

“Most places.”

“Why?”

He opened it. Needles, buttons, thread, tiny scissors, and a spool of blue thread filled the case.

“Because schools are full of things that come apart.”

The puppet’s head emerged from beneath his jacket. Its yarn hair was crushed flat, one blue button eye pointed toward the ceiling, and its torn collar hung loose beneath its crooked smile.

My stomach twisted.

“Can you fix it?”

“I can try.”

Outside, Tamara’s voice sharpened.

“Clarence, this is not your decision. Open the door now.”

He laid the puppet on the table.

“I’m sorry,” I said.

“For what?”

“For not stopping her.”

“You didn’t tear it.”

“I held on.”

“You were supposed to hold on.”

“I should’ve pulled harder.”

His hands stopped.

“Mae.”

I stared at the floor.

“If I’d pulled harder, she wouldn’t have gotten it.”

“If you’d pulled harder, she might have hurt your hand.”

“She wanted my spot.”

Clarence looked toward the door.

“Did she say that?”

“She didn’t have to.”

Applause rolled through the walls. Somewhere beyond us, another child began singing.

I imagined my name crossed out on Ms. Waverly’s clipboard, then Mabel under the closing spotlight.

My closing spotlight.

“She knew exactly what she was doing,” I said.

Clarence threaded a needle.

“How long have you worked here?” I asked.

“Twenty-six years.”

That meant he had been here before I was born. Before my mother met my father. Before Grandma got sick.

“Did you know my grandmother?”

The needle paused.

Outside, Tamara struck the door with her hand.

“Clarence!”

He pushed the needle through the puppet’s torn collar.

“I knew Frances Kendrick.”

“How?”

“I was a student here.”

I pictured him at ten years old, wearing a backpack and scuffed shoes.

“What grade?”

“Fourth.”

“Was Grandma your teacher?”

“Not exactly. She was the speech teacher.”

Grandma had mentioned children who hated reading aloud, children who could sing beautifully but couldn’t say their own names. She had never mentioned Clarence.

“She taught you?”

“Yes.”

“What was wrong with your speech?”

Clarence placed the needle back in the kit.

“Nothing was wrong with it.”

I lowered my eyes.

“Sorry.”

“Don’t be.”

He picked up the puppet’s head.

“My speech was mine. Other people decided it was a problem.”

The words settled in the small room.

“I stuttered badly,” he said. “Worse than you.”

I looked up.

He smiled faintly.

“I thought that would make you feel better.”

“It doesn’t.”

“No. It shouldn’t.”

A noise came from the hallway. Then Ms. Waverly’s voice joined Tamara’s.

“Clarence, this is becoming inappropriate.”

“I’m working,” he called.

“You were instructed to dispose of that puppet.”

“It’s being repaired.”

“That is not what I asked.”

Clarence’s needle went through the puppet’s neck. His hand shook once.

“Are they going to fire you?” I asked.

“If I don’t open the door?”

“If you keep helping me.”

“Maybe.”

“You shouldn’t risk your job.”

“Your grandmother risked more than that for me.”

“What did she do?”

“When I was in fourth grade, I wouldn’t speak in front of the class. Not one word.”

“Because you were scared?”

“Because I knew what would happen.”

He pressed the puppet’s head into place.

“Children laughed. Teachers rushed me. Adults finished my sentences. Every time I tried, people looked at my mouth instead of listening to what I meant.”

My thumb slipped inside the puppet’s patched sleeve.

“Frances noticed, too,” he said.

“What did she do?”

“She didn’t make me perform. She didn’t tell me to slow down or try harder. She sat beside me and asked me to say one word.”

“What word?”

“Home.”

“I couldn’t say it at first. I kept getting stuck on the H. Frances waited until the bell rang.”

“Did everyone leave?”

“Everyone except her.”

I pictured Grandma sitting in an empty classroom with a frightened boy.

“She waited until I said it.”

“Home?”

“Home.”

The word sounded steady, but not polished.

Real.

“What happened after that?”

“She asked for another word the next day. Sometimes I spoke through one of her puppets. Sometimes I pointed or wrote everything down. She told me the point wasn’t to sound like everybody else.”

“What was the point?”

“To be heard.”

He tied a knot beneath the puppet’s chin.

Up next