Part 2 of 9

“Give it to me.” My stepmother crushed my hearing aid and pinched my wrist, then a judge recognized one crooked mark on my mother’s handkerchief.

38 min read · November 15, 2026

I wanted the kitchen table. The recipe cards. The little blue handkerchief folded beside my plate. I wanted Mom to tap twice and tell me I was ready.

Instead, Herbert turned the hearing aid over in his palm.

The casing was split along one side.

A tiny metal hinge stuck out.

Water dripped from the crack.

“This device has been damaged,” he said.

“Obviously,” Rhonda replied. “It went into a fountain.”

“Not just wet. The casing was forced against something.”

Herbert lifted his eyes to Delaney.

“Was it the grate?”

Delaney didn’t answer.

Her mouth trembled.

Rhonda stepped in front of her.

“Mr. Sawyer, you are making an assumption based on a child’s panic.”

“No,” Herbert said. “I am examining an object.”

He brought the hearing aid closer to his face.

The other judges gathered around him.

I stood several feet away, unable to hear their words. I watched their expressions change as Herbert studied the cracked edge.

Then he turned to me.

“Kay, may I open this?”

I nodded.

“It belongs to me.”

“I know.”

He waited until I looked directly at him before continuing.

“I will not take anything from it. I only want to see what has been concealed inside the casing.”

Rhonda moved forward.

“There is nothing concealed inside that device.”

Herbert glanced at her.

“How would you know?”

The question landed harder than a shout.

Rhonda’s face tightened.

“I know because I have handled it before.”

“When?”

“It is a family item.”

“It is a hearing aid.”

“It was your late wife’s?” Mrs. Larkin asked.

Rhonda turned toward her.

“It was Kay’s mother’s. Kay keeps it for sentimental reasons.”

I shook my head.

The hearing aid had been mine.

Mom had helped me choose it. She had sat beside me in the clinic while the specialist adjusted the volume and asked me to identify different sounds.

The first thing I heard clearly through it was Mom crying.

She had turned away so I would not see.

I pointed at the hearing aid.

Then at my ear.

“Mine.”

Rhonda gave the committee a sad smile.

“She has difficulty separating memory from fact.”

Herbert’s jaw tightened.

He placed the hearing aid on the judging table.

The crack had widened when it struck the floor. He used the corner of a pencil to lift the loose edge.

Rhonda stepped toward him.

“Do not open that.”

Herbert stopped.

“Why not?”

“It could ruin it.”

“You already said it was only a keepsake.”

“It is still delicate.”

“Then you should not have removed the battery.”

Rhonda’s eyes flashed.

The battery was still in her closed hand.

I knew because she had never opened it.

Mrs. Larkin noticed the movement.

“Mrs. Oakley,” she said, “is the battery in your hand?”

Rhonda looked down as though surprised to find it there.

“I removed it to keep it from shorting out.”

“Then return it to Kay.”

“I was going to.”

She opened her hand.

The tiny battery lay in her palm.

It looked harmless.

It was smaller than my fingernail.

But seeing it there made my stomach twist.

Rhonda held it out to me.

I did not take it.

Herbert picked it up instead.

He examined the metal contacts, then placed it beside the hearing aid.

“Why did you remove it after the device had already been taken from the water?” he asked.

“To protect it.”

“From what?”

“From further damage.”

“Yet you gave the damaged device back to Delaney.”

Rhonda’s lips pressed together.

The gym had become a picture without sound, but I could still feel the pressure of everyone watching.

The woman from the front row had lowered her phone. Her camera was pointed toward the judges’ table now.

Rhonda saw it.

Her expression softened instantly.

“We are all trying to help Kay,” she said. “This is a very emotional day for her. I think everyone needs to remember that.”

Herbert reopened the casing.

The inside was dark with moisture.

A narrow strip of metal had been tucked beneath the removable panel. At first, I thought it was part of the device.

Then Herbert angled it toward the overhead lights.

Letters appeared.

He wiped the water away with the corner of the blue handkerchief.

The strip was a tag.

Small.

Rectangular.

Engraved.

He read it silently.

Then he looked at me.

“Kay Underwood,” he said.

My name.

The letters were plain and deep.

Underneath them were three words.

Harbor Hearing Fund.

The room seemed to tilt.

Rhonda reached for the device.

Herbert closed his hand around it.

“Where did this come from?” Mrs. Larkin asked.

Herbert held the tag where everyone could see.

“This aid was provided through the Harbor Hearing Fund.”

Rhonda gave a quick shake of her head.

“That proves nothing.”

“It has Kay’s name engraved on it.”

“Anyone could have put that there.”

“Why would anyone do that?”

“To make this look worse than it is,” Rhonda said. “Perhaps someone is trying to embarrass our family.”

Herbert stared at her.

“The fund provides hearing equipment to children who cannot afford replacements.”

“I’m aware of the fund.”

“Then you know this is not a sentimental keepsake.”

Rhonda’s face turned pink.

“I know what my family owns.”

“No,” Herbert said. “You know what your family has been given.”

A murmur moved through the bleachers.

I saw several people turn toward Rhonda.

She lifted her chin.

“Mr. Sawyer, you taught my husband’s first wife years ago. You have known Kay’s mother. It is obvious what is happening.”

Herbert said nothing.

“You are favoring Kay because of an old friendship.”

His fingers tightened around the hearing aid.

Up next