Part 4 of 10

“Give me that.” My stepmother snapped my mother’s harmonica against a metal stand, cutting my palm—then a blues guest recognized the engraved words.

41 min read · November 16, 2026

“Now.”

Slowly, Kay walked to the microphone.

She stood beneath the lights, alone.

The silver dress shimmered around her knees. The blue ribbon on her skirt caught the light.

She looked at it as if she had forgotten how it got there.

Joanne returned to the side of the stage.

She gave Kay a small nod.

The judges lifted their score sheets.

My father raised his phone again.

He aimed it at Kay.

Then he saw me watching him.

His hand dropped.

Otis stood beside me, still holding his battered hat.

“What do I do?” I whispered.

He looked at the broken harmonica.

“What did Lena tell you?”

“About the song?”

“About being afraid.”

I thought of my mother’s kitchen.

The yellow light.

The coffee cup.

Her pencil tapping against the table.

She had said, “Being afraid doesn’t mean you’re not ready. It means you know it matters.”

I had not told anyone that.

Not even my father.

Otis seemed to read the answer on my face.

“She knew you would find it,” he said.

“I stopped practicing.”

“Why?”

I stared at the floor.

“Because the last time I talked to her, we argued.”

Otis didn’t rush me.

I had been carrying the memory for so long that saying it felt like opening a door.

“She wanted me to play for her,” I whispered. “I said no.”

“Why?”

“I was tired. I told her I didn’t care about the song.”

My throat tightened.

“She left that night. Then the accident happened.”

Otis’s expression broke my heart because he did not look shocked.

He looked like he had heard a thousand people blame themselves for things they could not control.

“That was not your fault,” he said.

“You don’t know.”

“I know Lena.”

“She was mad at me.”

“She loved you.”

“You didn’t see her leave.”

“I saw her love you every time she played.”

The words pressed against the place inside me that had been hurting for two years.

I wanted to believe him.

I almost did.

Onstage, Kay took a breath.

Joanne raised one finger.

The signal.

Kay began singing.

The first phrase was thin and trembling.

But it was familiar.

It was the song I had come to play.

The song my mother had written with Otis.

The song Joanne had taught Kay to claim.

Otis closed his hand around the broken harmonica.

His gaze fixed on Kay as the melody rose through the gym.

Then he whispered, “That’s Lena’s arrangement.”

And Kay sang the next line.

Chapter 3

The song rose through the gym in a shape I knew better than my own handwriting.

Kay’s voice trembled on the first line.

Then it steadied.

Joanne stood beside the curtain, watching the judges instead of her daughter. Each time Kay reached the end of a phrase, Joanne gave a tiny nod, as if she were pulling invisible strings.

Otis did not look at Joanne.

He watched Kay’s hands.

Then her mouth.

Then the empty space between the notes.

“That’s Lena’s arrangement,” he said again.

This time, he did not whisper.

The microphone carried his words across the gym.

Kay stopped singing.

The final note faded into the rafters.

Joanne’s head snapped around.

“Mr. Brennan,” she said, “you are interrupting a child’s performance.”

“I’m identifying a song.”

“You heard it once tonight.”

“I heard it years ago.”

“You heard a similar melody.”

“No.”

Otis’s voice had changed. The warmth he had used during the afternoon workshop was gone. What remained was hard and quiet.

“I heard Lena’s song.”

Joanne walked toward the judges.

“Please excuse him. He has been traveling all day, and this situation has become emotional.”

“I’m not confused,” Otis said.

“You are making a public accusation against an eleven-year-old.”

“I’m making an accusation against the adult who taught her the song.”

A murmur rolled through the audience.

Joanne stopped.

Kay’s face went white.

My father stood near the side of the stage, phone hanging in his hand. He looked from Otis to Joanne, then at me.

For once, he did not look away quickly enough.

I saw the fear on his face.

Not fear for me.

Fear of what Joanne might say if the whole truth came out.

Joanne turned to the judges.

“This is absurd. Kay has practiced for weeks. She created this arrangement.”

Otis laughed once.

It was not a happy sound.

“Kay didn’t create that turn before the chorus.”

Joanne folded her arms.

“What turn?”

“The one she just sang. The note drops and catches before it resolves.”

“Anyone could do that.”

“Not the way Lena did it.”

He pointed toward Kay.

“Your daughter held the note exactly where Lena held it. Then she swallowed the last beat, because somebody taught her to breathe there.”

Kay’s eyes filled.

Joanne’s voice sharpened.

“You are exploiting a dead woman’s memory to get attention.”

Otis looked at the broken harmonica in my hand.

“I knew Lena before you ever heard her name.”

“Then you knew a woman who played music as a hobby.”

“I knew a songwriter.”

“You toured with professionals.”

“So did Lena.”

The gym seemed to tilt beneath me.

My mother had toured?

I remembered her telling people she did bookkeeping for a repair company. I remembered the envelopes of cash in the kitchen drawer and the nights she came home too tired to speak.

I remembered music coming through the walls.

I had always thought she was playing along with records.

Otis looked toward the judges.

Up next