Part 4 of 10

“Give that to me.” A woman slammed a piano lid on a boy’s fingers and tore his dead mother’s music—until an old judge saw the unfinished ending.

39 min read · November 15, 2026

“I will not sign this.”

Bonnie’s mouth fell open.

“You can’t do that.”

“I just did.”

He returned the silver pencil to his pocket and leaned close to me.

“After the ceremony,” he whispered, “play it for me from the beginning.”

I nodded.

The fair band began playing outside the tent.

People shifted in their chairs. Children ran past the open sides. The contest moved on as if nothing had happened.

As if my mother’s music had not been torn apart.

As if my fingers were not swelling inside my sleeves.

As if Lyle had not just played a stolen song and been called a winner.

Arlene came to stand beside me.

Her shoulder brushed mine.

To anyone watching, she looked like a worried older sister.

Her voice was soft.

“You embarrassed me.”

I said nothing.

“You embarrassed Lyle.”

I kept my eyes on the piano.

“You think that judge is going to save you?”

My fingers closed around the scrap.

“He knows my mother.”

Arlene went still.

Only for a second.

Then her hand found my wrist.

Her thumbnail pressed into the same bruised place.

“He knows nothing about us,” she whispered. “And by the time he learns anything, nobody will believe you.”

She released me and turned toward the crowd.

Her smile returned before she took a single step.

I watched her walk back to Lyle.

Albert watched too.

He had not moved from my side.

In his pocket, the old silver pencil tapped once against the torn scrap.

And somewhere inside the empty final measure, my mother’s unfinished music waited.

Chapter 3

The fair band kept playing, bright and careless, while Arlene stood beside Lyle and accepted congratulations.

People came to her with sympathetic faces.

“What a scene,” one woman murmured.

“Poor boy,” another said.

Arlene lowered her eyes as if she were fighting tears.

“I only wanted everyone to have a fair chance,” she whispered.

Her voice carried just far enough for me to hear.

Lyle remained on the piano bench. He kept rubbing the clean patch where the scholarship medal was supposed to go, though his hand was shaking now.

I stood beside Albert with my bruised fingers hidden inside my sleeves.

They throbbed with every heartbeat.

Albert watched the crowd gather around Arlene.

“Are you in pain?” he asked.

“Yes.”

“Badly?”

I looked at the swelling.

“Yes.”

“You should see a doctor.”

“I need to stay.”

“For what?”

“Because she’ll say I ran away.”

Albert’s face tightened.

“Let her say it.”

“She always says it when nobody is watching.”

He looked toward Bonnie. The coordinator was standing at the judges’ table, speaking rapidly into her phone while clutching the red clipboard against her chest.

“She has already decided what happened,” I said.

Albert followed my gaze.

“So have many of these people.”

“Then I have to stay.”

“Why?”

“Because if I leave, Arlene wins.”

Albert looked at me for a long moment.

Something in his expression changed. Not surprise. Recognition.

“Sometimes,” he said, “staying is the hardest form of courage.”

I did not feel courageous.

I felt sick.

My hands hurt. My throat hurt. My mother’s music was torn across the grass, and Lyle had played it in front of everyone while Arlene smiled beside him.

The people who had watched her crush my fingers were now congratulating her son.

Bonnie raised her clipboard.

“Lyle Chandler will receive the provisional scholarship medal at the awards table in ten minutes.”

A cheer rose from the nearest chairs.

Not a big cheer.

But enough.

Lyle’s shoulders jerked at the sound.

Arlene placed both hands on him.

“Smile,” she whispered.

He looked at her.

“Mom—”

“Smile.”

He did.

It was the saddest expression I had ever seen on his face.

Bonnie turned toward me.

“Jerome, you need to leave the performance area.”

“I’m not leaving.”

“You are disqualified.”

“You said provisional.”

“Your disqualification is not provisional.”

“Then why is Lyle’s award provisional?”

Bonnie’s lips pressed together.

“Because the committee will review the incident.”

“The incident where Arlene hurt me?”

“The incident where you disrupted another contestant.”

“She stole the music.”

“You have made that accusation several times.”

“Because it’s true.”

Arlene came toward us, one hand resting over her heart.

“Bonnie, please don’t argue with him.”

“I’m not arguing,” I said.

Arlene gave the crowd a tired smile.

“He’s frightened. He doesn’t understand what’s happening.”

“I understand perfectly.”

“No, Jerome. You don’t.”

She leaned closer.

Her voice stayed gentle.

“You lost your temper. You frightened Lyle. You interrupted his performance. And now you’re trying to make everyone punish him because you’re embarrassed.”

I looked at Lyle.

“Tell her.”

His face twisted.

“Tell her what?”

“That she took the pages.”

Arlene’s fingers tightened on his shoulder.

Lyle looked at me, then at the ground.

“I don’t know what you mean.”

The words landed softly.

They still cut.

Arlene turned to Bonnie.

“You see?”

Bonnie nodded.

“Jerome, you need to go with Arlene.”

I stepped backward.

“No.”

Her eyes narrowed.

“Excuse me?”

“I’m not going with her.”

“She is your foster sister and responsible for you today.”

“She hurt me.”

“We have discussed that.”

Up next