Part 7 of 9

“I need my baby,” I cried from grass after my husband shoved me onto my stitches, as a neighbor spotted matching red marks—what did they mean?

38 min read · November 17, 2026

I pressed play.

The first sound was Jerome’s voice.

Clear.

Calm.

Close enough to touch.

“Is she still at the hospital?”

And from somewhere beside him, Marjorie answered.

“She’ll be home soon.”

Jerome reached for the restroom door.

I turned up the volume.

Chapter 4

“Is she still at the hospital?”

Jerome’s voice came through the phone, clear and calm.

“She’ll be home soon,” Marjorie answered.

I pressed the speaker against my palm.

Outside the stall, Jerome rattled the door.

“Colleen, open this. We need to leave.”

On the recording, he spoke again.

“Good. The locks are changed?”

“They were changed yesterday.”

“And her things?”

“Outside. Just like you said.”

My knees weakened.

I lowered myself onto the closed toilet and held Oakley against my chest.

Marjorie’s recorded voice sounded almost cheerful.

“She’ll see them when she arrives.”

“She needs to see the baby first,” Jerome said. “If she gets inside, she’ll start making decisions.”

“She won’t be getting inside.”

“Keep Oakley behind the door. Let her hear him. Let her see him, but don’t hand him over.”

My breath caught.

On the other side of the stall, Jerome stopped rattling the door.

“What are you doing in there?” he demanded.

I did not answer.

The recording continued.

Marjorie asked, “What if she starts screaming?”

“Then let the neighbors hear it.”

“And if she cries?”

“Even better. She’s exhausted. She’ll look unstable.”

A long silence followed.

Then Marjorie laughed softly.

“They’ll believe you.”

“They already do.”

The stall door shook beneath Jerome’s hand.

“Colleen, turn that off.”

His voice was no longer calm.

On the recording, Marjorie said, “What exactly am I supposed to tell people?”

Jerome answered without hesitation.

“That she abandoned Oakley.”

“I don’t want to say she left him willingly if someone asks when she was discharged.”

“Say she said she couldn’t do it anymore. Say she handed him to us and walked away.”

“But she’s coming home.”

“Not as his mother.”

The words seemed to drain the air from the restroom.

I looked down at Oakley.

His eyes were closed. His cheek rested beneath my chin.

On the recording, Jerome continued.

“Once she gets upset, we call the sheriff. We tell them she’s unstable and tried to force her way in.”

Marjorie inhaled slowly.

“And Oakley?”

“I’ll say you’ve been his dependable caregiver.”

“You want me to keep him?”

“I want you to raise him properly.”

A pause.

Then Marjorie said, “What about Colleen?”

“Supervised visits. Public handoffs. Nothing private.”

“And if she fights?”

“She won’t have the money or the proof.”

My finger trembled over the screen.

Jerome’s recorded voice became colder.

“By the time everyone hears the story, she’ll be grateful they let her see him at all.”

A knock sounded against the stall door.

“Colleen,” Hugh called from outside. “It’s me.”

Jerome said something too low for me to hear.

Hugh answered, “Step away from the door.”

I unlocked the stall.

Hugh stood between me and Jerome. His bandaged hand was pressed against the doorframe. Lucille stood behind him, one hand over her heart.

Jerome’s attorney was at the restroom entrance.

Marjorie stood beside him, pale and rigid.

The recording still played.

“I want the family to hear her say she can’t do it,” Marjorie’s voice said from my phone.

Jerome’s lawyer glanced at his client.

Jerome’s face had gone gray.

“I want them to understand that she is not safe alone with Oakley.”

On the phone, Jerome answered, “Then send them only the part where she says she’s done.”

The recording clicked.

Then my own voice filled the restroom.

Weak.

Exhausted.

“I can’t do this anymore without sleep.”

My heart clenched.

The recording should have ended there.

That was the piece Jerome had sent to the family.

That was the sentence printed in the court transcript.

But the file continued.

My voice broke into a sob.

“I can’t do this anymore without sleep, but I will do anything to bring my son home safely.”

No one moved.

I heard the recording of myself whispering through tears.

“I don’t care if I have to stay awake all night. I don’t care if I’m afraid. I will do anything to bring Oakley home safely.”

Then the nurse’s voice sounded faintly in the background.

“He’s right here, Colleen.”

My recorded voice answered, “I know. I’m coming back for him.”

The file ended.

For several seconds, there was only the hum of the restroom lights.

Then Lucille began to cry.

Not loudly.

Just one broken sound that seemed to come from somewhere deep inside her.

Marjorie looked at me.

“You don’t understand what we were trying to do.”

“I understand exactly.”

“We were protecting Oakley.”

“You planned to make everyone believe I abandoned him before I even reached the house.”

“You were exhausted.”

“I was his mother.”

“You said you couldn’t do it.”

“Without sleep,” I said. “I said I couldn’t do it without sleep.”

Jerome took one step toward me.

Hugh moved in front of him.

“Do not come any closer.”

Jerome’s attorney reached for his arm.

“Say nothing.”

But Jerome was no longer looking at the attorney.

He was looking at my phone.

“You recorded me.”

“I recorded the truth.”

“You violated—”

“Your client just admitted the plan on a recording made before Mrs. Lawson reached the residence,” Hugh said. “I suggest you stop speaking.”

The attorney looked at Hugh with open anger.

“You are not counsel here.”

“No,” Hugh said. “I am a witness.”

“And a retired judge who has clearly chosen a side.”

“I chose the side of the facts.”

The court clerk came running from the hallway.

Up next