Part 6 of 9

Less than six hours after my C-section, my mother-in-law pulled my IV and carried my newborn away—then the nurse saw the 1989 infant band in my pouch.

38 min read · November 15, 2026

“The entry says she identified herself as Theresa Prescott.”

Gary stared at his mother.

No one spoke.

The hospital sounds seemed to disappear.

Theresa’s mouth opened, but no words came.

Gary looked at me.

Then back at Theresa.

“Your name is on that record.”

“She wrote it down wrong.”

“Your name?”

“She must have misunderstood.”

“You were here?”

“No.”

“You said you had never been to Pinehaven Memorial before.”

Theresa’s eyes darted toward the elevator.

“I said I didn’t remember coming here.”

“That is not what you said.”

“I was under stress.”

“You were not even born here,” I said.

She turned toward me.

“Don’t.”

“You left me here.”

“I did not.”

“The record says you did.”

“The record is wrong.”

“Why would your name be there?”

“Because Alice wanted to blame me.”

That name struck Theresa harder than Marian’s accusation.

Gary looked from one woman to the other.

“Alice blamed you?”

Theresa’s expression crumpled.

“She hated me.”

“Why?”

“She was jealous.”

“Of what?”

“Of my life.”

I stared at Theresa.

My mother had never spoken about her with anger.

Not once.

She had never called Theresa a bad person.

She had only told me that some people were not safe to trust.

“Who were you to Alice?” I asked.

Theresa’s eyes shifted away.

Marian answered.

“In 1989, Theresa Prescott was married to Cecilia’s maternal uncle.”

Gary looked at me.

“What does that mean?”

“It means she was your aunt by marriage,” Marian said.

The words landed in the hallway.

Theresa closed her eyes.

I felt the blood leave my face.

My aunt.

Not by blood.

But family.

Someone who had known my mother.

Someone who had held me before walking away.

Gary shook his head.

“That’s impossible.”

“You and Cecilia are not related,” Marian continued. “Theresa left that marriage later. She had you with another man.”

Gary looked at his mother.

“You were married to Cecilia’s uncle?”

Theresa’s lips trembled.

“I was young.”

“And you knew Cecilia?”

“I knew the family.”

“Did you know her mother?”

“She was not my sister.”

“Did you know the baby in this record?”

Theresa pressed one hand against the wall.

“Gary, please.”

“Did you know Cecilia?”

She looked at me.

Her eyes were full of something I had never seen in them before.

Not love.

Not regret.

Recognition.

“You were a difficult child,” she said.

My breath caught.

I had been two hours old.

A newborn found alone in a hallway.

And she called me difficult.

Gary took a step backward.

“What did you say?”

Theresa’s face hardened again.

“She cried constantly. Alice wanted everyone to believe she was some kind of saint for taking her.”

“She took me because you left me.”

“I didn’t abandon you.”

“You walked away.”

“I gave her a chance.”

“You left me on a hospital floor.”

“I knew Alice would take care of you.”

The hallway erupted in whispers.

The visitors near the nurses’ station stared openly now.

The hospital aide lifted the phone again.

Gary looked sick.

“You knew?”

Theresa turned toward him.

“I was trying to protect you.”

“From what?”

“From this family.”

“You never told me Cecilia was part of your family.”

“She wasn’t.”

“You were married to her uncle.”

“That marriage was over.”

“After you left the baby?”

Theresa’s face twisted.

“Don’t you dare judge me.”

“You lied to me.”

“I protected you.”

“You let me marry her without telling me.”

“You and Cecilia are not related.”

“That is not the point!”

His voice echoed down the floor.

My son stirred inside the family room.

The sound of his small cry reached us through the glass.

I took one step toward him.

Pain cut through my abdomen, but I kept moving.

Theresa turned at once.

She saw where I was going.

She reached through the family-room doorway and grabbed the baby from the chair.

“Gary,” I said.

He stepped in front of her.

“Give him back to Cecilia.”

Theresa pulled the baby against her.

“No.”

“You heard what she said,” Gary told her. “Give him back.”

“She is not fit to raise him.”

“You abandoned her.”

“I did not abandon anyone.”

“You just admitted you left her.”

“I admitted nothing.”

Marian shut the binder.

“Mrs. Prescott, hand the infant to his mother.”

Theresa backed toward the elevator.

Gary moved with her.

“Mom, stop.”

“I am taking him somewhere safe.”

“You are not taking him anywhere.”

“You don’t understand what she is.”

“I understand what you are.”

Her face went white.

He had never spoken to her that way.

Neither had I.

Theresa pressed the elevator button.

The doors opened.

“Gary,” I said, “do not let her leave.”

He stood between us, but he did not reach for the baby.

Theresa stepped into the elevator.

Gary followed.

His body blocked my view of my son.

“Move,” I told him.

“Cecilia—”

“Move.”

Theresa lifted her chin.

“You’re too weak to stop me.”

I gripped the wheelchair and pushed myself forward.

The nurse tried to steady me.

“Mrs. Prescott, please.”

“No.”

The elevator doors began to close.

My son cried.

Gary looked at me through the narrowing gap.

I saw shame on his face.

I saw fear.

But I also saw him still standing beside his mother.

“If you let those doors close,” I said, “you are choosing her over us.”

Theresa reached for the control panel.

The doors slid inward.

Marian stepped toward the elevator.

“Security is on its way,” she said.

Theresa’s smile returned, thin and merciless.

“Then they’d better hurry.”

The doors were almost closed.

Up next