Part 1 of 10

“Let go of me!” My classmate ripped away my prosthetic cover and dropped it into a filthy toilet—then the school nurse saw one tiny star.

42 min read · November 17, 2026

Chapter 2

STORY CONTINUES

Geraldine plunged her bare hand into the filthy bowl.

Priscilla’s fingers were still pressing the flush handle.

For one second, the two women stood there, frozen in opposite directions—Priscilla trying to make the evidence disappear, Geraldine reaching into the water to save it.

Then Geraldine found the cover.

She pulled it free just as the toilet began to roar.

Water surged around her wrist. The painted shell struck the porcelain, and Geraldine caught it against the side of the bowl before it could vanish.

“Let go of that handle!” she snapped.

Priscilla released it.

The toilet continued gulping for another terrible second before the water slowed.

Geraldine lifted the cover out.

Gray water ran from the cracked butterfly and dripped onto the tile.

I stared at it.

The blue paint was streaked with brown. One poppy had split down the middle. The monarch’s left wing hung in a curled flap.

But the signature was still there.

Frances.

And inside the final letter, the tiny yellow star shone through the grime.

Geraldine held the cover in both hands.

Her cardigan sleeve was soaked to the elbow.

Nobody spoke.

Then Principal Terrence Goodwin stepped fully into the locker room.

He was wearing his gray suit, the one he wore for school-board meetings and photographs in the newspaper. His silver pen gleamed in his breast pocket.

He looked first at his daughter.

Then at Geraldine’s wet hand.

Then at me kneeling beside the toilet.

His face settled into the concerned expression adults used when they had already decided what had happened.

“What is going on?” he asked.

Priscilla moved toward him.

“Dad, Rosie attacked me.”

Her voice trembled perfectly.

“She got upset during the video, tore off her own cover, and threw it in the toilet. When I tried to stop her, she shoved me.”

“That isn’t true,” I said.

My voice sounded small in the tiled room.

Terrence looked at me.

“Rosie, stand up.”

“I didn’t throw it.”

“Stand up, please.”

“I didn’t attack her.”

His silver pen clicked once.

A tiny sound.

I remembered seeing him do it during assemblies whenever a student was called to the office. Click. Click. Click.

He said it helped him think.

Now he clicked it again.

Geraldine stepped between us, still holding the cover.

“She removed the cover from Rosie’s prosthetic,” she said. “Then she dropped it into the toilet.”

Priscilla’s mouth fell open.

“Mrs. Shepherd, I was trying to help her.”

“You were holding a phone.”

“It was a charity video.”

“It was a video of a child in distress.”

Priscilla looked at her father.

“Dad.”

That one word carried everything she needed it to carry.

Not fear.

Not a request.

An order.

Terrence’s expression tightened for half a second. Then the school-principal smile returned.

“Let’s all lower our voices,” he said. “There’s clearly been a misunderstanding.”

I almost laughed.

A misunderstanding.

My mother’s painting was dripping toilet water onto the floor.

My arm was bare in front of half the girls in seventh-grade gym.

Priscilla had filmed me crying.

And the principal was calling it a misunderstanding.

Geraldine looked down at the cover.

“Rosie, this belongs to you.”

She held it out.

I stood too quickly. My knee slipped on the wet tile, and I caught myself against the stall wall.

Geraldine reached for my elbow.

I flinched before I could stop myself.

She let go immediately.

“I’m sorry,” she said.

That simple apology nearly broke me.

Not because she had hurt me.

Because she had noticed.

I took the cover from her.

It was heavier than before, soaked through and cold. Water ran over my fingers. The painted vines blurred beneath my thumb.

I pressed the shell against my chest.

Mom’s signature touched my cheek.

Terrence watched me hold it.

“Geraldine,” he said, “please take that to the nurse’s office and place it in a sealed bag.”

“No.”

The word came from me.

Terrence’s eyebrows rose.

“It needs to be cleaned properly,” he said. “You’ll damage it further if you handle it.”

“I can take care of it.”

“You are upset.”

“I can still take care of it.”

Priscilla folded her arms.

“She’s being difficult again.”

The girls behind her shifted.

Some looked at the floor. Others watched me with the uneasy curiosity people had when they expected a fight but hoped they would not have to join it.

Terrence turned to Geraldine.

“Please take the cover.”

Geraldine didn’t move.

“Mr. Goodwin,” she said quietly, “Rosie is the owner.”

“I understand that.”

“Then she should decide what happens to it.”

His silver pen clicked again.

“Geraldine.”

The room changed when he said her name.

I had heard that tone before. Not directed at me, but at teachers who stayed too long in his office or parents who asked questions during board meetings.

It was polite.

It was also a warning.

Geraldine’s fingers tightened around the edge of her cardigan pocket.

“I’ll wrap it in clean towels,” she said. “But Rosie should come with me.”

“Rosie should go to class.”

“I’m not going to class,” I said.

Terrence looked at me.

“You have gym.”

“I’m not going back in there.”

“You cannot leave class whenever you are upset.”

“I’m not leaving. I’m standing here.”

Priscilla gave a soft little laugh.

“See? This is what I was talking about.”

I turned toward her.

“What were you talking about?”

She lifted her phone.

The screen showed my face.

My knees on the floor.

My uncovered arm.

My mother’s painting disappearing into the toilet.

Up next