Part 3 of 10

“Let go of me!” My classmate ripped away my prosthetic cover and dropped it into a filthy toilet—then the school nurse saw one tiny star.

42 min read · November 17, 2026

Priscilla’s father looked at the cover again.

The star sat inside the final curl of Frances’s name, bright against the ruined paint.

“I know Frances’s signature,” he said.

“You know what the star means?”

“I know it’s part of her design.”

“No,” Geraldine said. “It isn’t just a design.”

Something passed over his face.

A memory, maybe.

Or fear.

I looked between them.

“What does it mean?”

Geraldine’s eyes softened when she turned back to me.

“It was Frances’s private mark.”

“What kind of mark?”

“She used it for children who needed to remember something.”

“What?”

Geraldine glanced at Terrence.

He clicked his pen once.

“Geraldine,” he said.

She ignored him.

“She used to say that children who wore supports or braces got tired of being looked at as if they were broken,” Geraldine said. “So she hid a star somewhere only the child might find it.”

I looked down at the cover.

The yellow star had always been there.

I had seen it hundreds of times.

I thought it was just the way Mom signed her name.

“What did it remind them of?”

Geraldine swallowed.

“That they were seen. Not pitied.”

My throat tightened.

The locker room seemed to tilt around me.

Mom had painted this at the kitchen table while her hand shook.

One more little thing.

I had thought she meant the butterfly.

I had thought she was trying to finish what I asked for before she became too tired.

Geraldine reached out, but stopped before touching me.

“Frances told me the star was for the wearer,” she said. “Not for everyone else to admire.”

Terrence’s face had become carefully blank.

“An interesting story,” he said.

“It’s not a story.”

“It’s irrelevant to the disciplinary issue.”

“How is it irrelevant?” I asked.

“Because a sentimental marking does not excuse physical aggression.”

“I didn’t attack her.”

“I’ll be collecting statements from everyone involved.”

“Then collect the video.”

His eyes moved to Priscilla’s pocket.

“She recorded the incident.”

“She recorded what she wanted people to see.”

“That will be determined.”

“She kept saying it was a charity video.”

Terrence’s eyebrows lifted.

“Was it?”

Priscilla’s voice came from the doorway.

She had not gone to class.

She stood just outside the room, phone in hand, wearing an expression of wounded innocence.

“I was trying to raise awareness,” she said.

Terrence looked at her for a long moment.

Then his face softened.

“Of course you were.”

The anger that rose in me was so hot it pushed the tears back.

Geraldine looked at him.

“Terrence.”

He ignored her.

“Priscilla, send the recording to me.”

She tapped the screen.

“It’s already uploading.”

“Good.”

“It shows everything.”

“No,” I said. “It doesn’t.”

Priscilla turned the phone toward me.

The screen was too bright to see clearly, but I recognized the first image: my face, frightened and close to the camera.

She had cut out the part where her fingers hooked beneath the cover.

Of course she had.

Terrence held out his hand.

“Give me the phone.”

Priscilla handed it over.

He watched the clip in silence.

I could hear my own voice through the small speaker.

Thank me for raising awareness, Rosie.

Then my refusal.

Then the sound of the clasp breaking.

But the video jumped.

It showed me shouting.

It showed Madison holding my wrist.

It showed me on the floor.

The toilet.

The cover.

My face.

The moment where Priscilla said, She attacked me.

Nothing before it.

Nothing that explained why.

Terrence stopped the video.

“This is sufficient for now.”

“It’s edited,” I said.

“You don’t know that.”

“I was there.”

“We will review it.”

“With who?”

“With the people responsible for investigating student conduct.”

“You’re the principal.”

“Exactly.”

He put the phone in his suit pocket.

I stared at him.

“You’re taking her video?”

“I’m preserving it.”

“Are you taking my cover too?”

“Yes.”

“No.”

His expression hardened.

“Rosie, hand it over.”

I held it closer.

“I’m not giving you my mother’s painting.”

“Then I will have to ask Geraldine to take it.”

Geraldine stood very still.

Her blue cardigan sleeve dripped onto the floor.

“Don’t,” I whispered.

She looked at me.

I knew she was caught.

If she refused him, she could lose her job.

If she obeyed, my mother’s last painting would disappear into the same place as every truth nobody wanted to see.

Terrence extended his hand.

“Geraldine.”

She looked at the cover.

At the yellow star.

Then she looked at me.

“You don’t have to give it to him,” she said.

Terrence’s eyes narrowed.

“I beg your pardon?”

“I said Rosie doesn’t have to surrender personal property without a documented reason.”

“I just gave you the reason.”

“You gave me an accusation.”

His silver pen clicked.

Once.

Twice.

The sound seemed louder now.

“I am ordering you to place the item in the incident evidence envelope.”

“Then write the order down.”

The silence afterward was enormous.

Priscilla stared at Geraldine as if she had never seen an adult refuse her father before.

Terrence’s face lost its public warmth.

“Be careful.”

Geraldine’s chin lifted.

“I have been careful for twenty-eight years.”

“And I have been principal here for nine.”

“I know.”

“Your employment depends on your ability to follow administrative directives.”

“I know that too.”

My fingers trembled around the cover.

Geraldine turned to me.

“Rosie, I can wrap it in clean towels and store it in the nurse’s office. You can take it home at dismissal.”

I looked at Terrence.

He was waiting for me to fight.

Up next