Part 7 of 10

“Let go of me!” My classmate ripped away my prosthetic cover and dropped it into a filthy toilet—then the school nurse saw one tiny star.

42 min read · November 17, 2026

“I told myself keeping copies was doing something,” she continued. “I told myself I could protect students better from inside the school than outside it. But mostly, I was afraid of what would happen to Walter if I lost my job.”

She placed both hands over the reports.

“Today, I watched Priscilla put her hand on that flush handle. I realized being afraid had made me useful to Terrence.”

“You saved the cover.”

“This time.”

She stood and unlocked the cabinet.

When she opened the plastic box, the clean towels smelled faintly of soap.

Mom’s painting lay between them.

The crack through the poppy remained. The butterfly’s wing had been laid flat, though some of the orange paint was gone.

The yellow star still shone inside her signature.

Geraldine set the box beside the reports.

“Your mother was braver than I have been.”

A hard knot formed in my throat.

“She shouldn’t have finished it.”

“What?”

“The cover.”

I stared at the butterfly.

“She was already sick. Her hands shook, and she got tired just walking from the bedroom to the kitchen.”

“Rosie—”

“I asked her for one more design.”

My voice cracked.

“She had finished the flowers, but I wanted a butterfly. I kept talking about how empty that spot looked. So she stayed up and painted it.”

I touched the curled edge of the damaged wing.

“She got worse after that.”

Geraldine moved closer.

“You think painting this made your mother sicker?”

“I made her keep going.”

“No.”

“You weren’t there.”

“No,” she said. “But I knew Frances.”

“She could barely hold the brush.”

“Then she could have put it down.”

“She didn’t because I asked.”

Geraldine shook her head.

“Your mother did not finish this because you were a burden.”

My eyes burned.

“I didn’t say I was.”

“You didn’t have to.”

I tapped the plain black sleeve.

Tap.

Tap.

Geraldine pointed to the yellow star.

“Frances chose that mark before you asked for the butterfly. She knew what she wanted you to find.”

“What?”

“That needing help did not make you less whole. And loving you was not a debt she had to pay.”

I looked away.

“She died tired.”

“She lived loving you.”

That hurt worse.

A knock sounded at the door.

Three quick taps.

Geraldine gathered the reports, but before she could hide them, a voice came through the door.

“It’s Colleen.”

I stared at Geraldine.

She opened the door just far enough to look outside, then pulled Colleen in.

Colleen’s face was pale.

She kept rubbing the same cracked thumbnail.

“What are you doing here?” I asked.

“I told my teacher I felt sick.”

“You lied for Priscilla.”

“I know.”

“You said I attacked her.”

“I know.”

Her eyes filled with tears.

I didn’t care.

Not yet.

Colleen took her phone from her pocket.

“Priscilla sent everyone an edited clip,” she said. “She made us delete anything else we recorded.”

“Anything else?” Geraldine asked.

Colleen nodded.

“She planned it in our group chat last night. She said we were going to make Rosie freak out so Mr. Goodwin would remove her from the mural.”

My stomach turned.

“You knew?”

“I thought she was only going to embarrass you.”

“That makes it better?”

“No.”

Colleen rubbed her thumb until the crack opened again.

“I saved the original video.”

The room went silent.

“What original?” I asked.

“The whole thing. I started recording before we went into the locker room because Priscilla wanted different angles.”

She unlocked her phone.

The video began with Priscilla standing outside the locker-room door.

Her voice came through clearly.

Once Rosie loses it, Dad will call her unstable. Then she’s off the mural.

Madison laughed.

Priscilla added, Make sure you get her arm.

My knees weakened.

The recording showed them blocking the exit.

It showed Priscilla hooking her fingers beneath my cover.

It showed Madison grabbing my wrist.

It showed the cover dropping into the toilet.

And it showed me pushing Priscilla’s hand away only after she grabbed my shoulder.

Nobody could call that an altercation.

Nobody could say it was an accident.

Geraldine held out her hand.

“May I?”

Colleen gave her the phone.

“Priscilla thinks I deleted it,” she said. “I hid it in another folder.”

Geraldine watched enough to confirm the beginning, then stopped the video.

“We need to take this to the superintendent and the board.”

A shadow moved beneath the office door.

The handle turned.

Locked.

Then Terrence’s voice came from the hallway.

“Geraldine, open this door.”

Colleen went white.

“How did he know?”

Terrence knocked harder.

“Open the door now.”

Geraldine slid the reports beneath the folded towels in Mom’s box.

She handed Colleen’s phone back.

“Do not unlock that for anyone.”

The pounding stopped.

A key entered the lock.

Terrence stepped inside.

His eyes moved from me to Colleen, then to the open cabinet.

His silver pen was already in his hand.

“What is going on?”

“Colleen feels ill,” Geraldine said.

“No, she doesn’t.”

His gaze dropped to the phone.

“Give me that.”

Colleen gripped it against her chest.

“It’s mine.”

“You recorded students in a locker room. That device is now evidence in a serious privacy investigation.”

The words came too quickly.

He knew.

“Priscilla recorded me,” I said.

“That matter is being reviewed.”

“Colleen has the original.”

Terrence’s expression changed.

Only for a second.

Then the pen clicked.

“Give me the phone, Colleen.”

She looked at Geraldine.

Terrence stepped closer.

“If you refuse, I will contact your parents and recommend immediate suspension for recording students while changing.”

Up next