Part 4 of 9

“Move,” my stepbrother said as his shoe crushed a nine-year-old boy’s prism glasses. Then Dad found Mom’s hidden words inside the bent frame—what did they mean?

36 min read · November 15, 2026

The first line was supposed to be mine. I had practiced it until the words felt worn smooth inside my head.

“On a night when the world was waiting,” Curtis repeated, louder this time, “the light of hope appeared…”

He paused.

Denise stood just beyond the curtain, smiling toward the congregation. Her fingers moved behind her back.

One.

Two.

Three.

She was counting for him.

Curtis saw the signal and continued.

“The light of hope appeared in the—”

He stopped again.

The church was silent enough for me to hear the heating pipes knock beneath the floor.

Curtis had the narration in his hands, my robe on his shoulders, and the microphone. But he didn’t have the words.

Denise leaned toward the stage.

“The humble town,” she whispered.

“The humble town of Bethlehem.”

A few people smiled. They thought he was nervous. They didn’t know he had never learned the passage.

I did.

I knew the next sentence, every word after it, where the choir would enter, where the shepherd children would cross, and how long Mrs. Whitaker wanted the pause before star.

My fingers tightened around the broken frame.

Dad looked at me.

“Are you all right?”

“Yes.”

“You don’t have to do anything.”

“I know.”

Across the stage, Curtis continued.

“The humble town of Bethlehem was quiet beneath the winter sky.”

His voice steadied for three lines. Then he reached the passage with the old names.

“From the house of David came Joseph, son of—”

Curtis stopped.

“Jacob,” Denise hissed.

“Joseph, son of Jacob, traveled with Mary, his betrothed, through the—”

“Through the hills.”

“Through the hills,” Curtis said.

Behind him, the choir began singing early. Mrs. Whitaker must have seen the trouble and signaled them to cover the silence.

The music swelled.

Curtis read the next lines too quickly.

“While the town slept, the travelers searched for a place to rest, and the night grew colder, and the stars…”

He faltered.

The next sentence had twelve words. I knew all twelve.

“The stars appeared like promises in the darkness.”

Curtis stared at the page.

His mouth opened.

The promise died there.

I whispered the line behind the curtain.

“The stars appeared like promises in the darkness.”

A little girl in a white angel dress turned toward me. Molly was six, and she clutched a paper star against her chest.

“Lawson knows it,” she whispered.

I pressed a finger to my lips.

Onstage, Curtis guessed.

“The stars appeared like… lights in the darkness.”

A few people shifted in their seats. Mrs. Whitaker looked down at her clipboard.

Denise turned sharply toward me. Her eyes found mine through the gap in the curtain.

She grabbed my arm above the elbow.

“Storage alcove,” she whispered.

“I’m not going.”

“I know the words.”

“No one asked you.”

“He needs help.”

“He needs you to stop.”

She pulled me away from the curtain.

The storage alcove stood behind a folding screen near the costume racks, crowded with Christmas decorations, folding chairs, and a plastic tub labeled NATIVITY.

“Get in.”

“I can still hear the pageant.”

“That’s the idea.”

“I didn’t do anything.”

“You are sabotaging Curtis.”

“I whispered one line.”

“You whispered where people could hear you.”

“Molly heard me.”

Denise looked past me. Molly had followed us halfway across the basement.

“Go back to your place,” Denise told her.

Molly stared at Denise, then at me.

“Lawson knows the whole story.”

Denise’s face hardened.

“He is not part of the story anymore.”

Molly’s lower lip trembled.

“Go.”

The little girl hurried away.

I stepped into the alcove.

“If you come out,” Denise whispered, “I’ll tell your father you refused to obey and caused Curtis to lose his place.”

“He already knows you lied.”

“He knows what I tell him.”

“You said Dad agreed.”

“And he will agree if you make this difficult.”

She leaned closer.

“Curtis is on that stage because your father chose him.”

“That’s not true.”

“It will be true by the time the pageant ends.”

Then she closed the screen.

The sound from the sanctuary came through the gap in broken pieces: the piano, the choir, Curtis’s voice, Denise’s whispers.

Without my glasses, everything was pale shapes and moving shadows. But I knew the story. I had placed every sentence in my mind like a row of Christmas lights.

Curtis made it through a simple paragraph about the sleeping town. Then came the passage about the shepherds, the one that began in the fields outside Bethlehem and ended with the angels appearing in the sky.

“Some passages have to sound like they are opening a door,” Mrs. Whitaker had told me. “Don’t rush them.”

Curtis rushed them.

“The shepherds were watching their flocks by night when suddenly the heavens became bright and the angels appeared and told them not to be afraid because the Savior had been born in the city of David, which was Bethlehem, and they—”

He stopped.

“The glory of the Lord,” Denise hissed.

“The glory of the Lord.”

“Shone around them.”

“Shone around them.”

“Do not be afraid.”

“Do not be afraid.”

The choir director raised both hands. Music covered the pause.

Then I heard Curtis whisper, “What comes next?”

“Read the page,” Denise answered.

“I can’t find it.”

Up next