Part 1 of 9

“Please.” A limping student watches his father’s glove sink into a grease bin; his bad leg buckles, then a groundskeeper finds blue writing that makes the coach turn pale.

39 min read · November 16, 2026

Chapter 2

STORY CONTINUES

Otis pulled me through the cafeteria doors and into the hallway.

I stumbled after him, my bad leg dragging for two steps before it caught up.

“Slow down,” I gasped.

“Can’t.”

“You said run.”

“I said it because I needed you moving.”

He kept one hand around my wrist and the other pressed against the glove beneath his shirt. Grease had soaked through the leather and stained his gray work shirt in a dark, ugly patch.

Behind us, chairs scraped the floor.

Dalton shouted, “Stop him!”

Otis didn’t stop.

The hallway outside the cafeteria was empty except for a row of blue lockers and a mop bucket parked beneath the drinking fountain. Sunlight came through the high windows in pale rectangles.

Otis pulled me around the corner.

Then he let go.

My wrist tingled where his fingers had been.

“What’s the name?” I asked.

Otis looked back toward the cafeteria.

“Not here.”

“You saw it.”

“I saw enough.”

“What does it say?”

“Sam—”

“What does it say?”

My voice cracked on the last word.

Otis studied me. He had known my father. Not well enough to come to our house for dinner, maybe, but well enough to say Isaac’s name without that careful pause people used after he died.

He reached beneath his shirt and brought out the glove.

It looked worse than before.

Grease darkened the leather. A clump of mashed potatoes clung to the webbing. The inner lining had split open beneath the crooked star my father had sewn by hand.

Otis held it between us.

“Your father made this for you?”

“Yes.”

“And you’re certain it wasn’t school property?”

“My father gave it to me.”

“I know.”

He said it so firmly that my throat tightened.

“Then why did Coach Kendrick believe Dalton?”

“Because he wanted to.”

The answer was so simple it hurt.

Footsteps sounded behind us.

Otis shoved the glove back under his shirt.

A teacher appeared at the corner, followed by Coach Kendrick and Dalton.

Dalton was still wearing his father’s too-short team jacket. The sleeves stopped above his wrists. He looked pleased with himself.

Coach Kendrick did not.

His face had regained its color, but his mouth was set in a hard line.

“Sam,” he said. “Come here.”

Otis stepped in front of me.

“We’re going to the equipment shed.”

“You’re not taking that glove anywhere,” Coach Kendrick said.

Otis’s hand tightened around the leather beneath his shirt.

“It needs cleaning.”

“It’s school property.”

“No, it isn’t.”

Dalton pointed at me.

“He admitted he took it.”

“I did not,” I said.

“You said your dad gave it to you,” Dalton replied. “That doesn’t mean he had the right to give it away.”

“My dad bought it.”

“From the team?”

“From a flea market.”

Dalton laughed.

“Sure.”

Coach Kendrick held out his hand.

“Give me the glove, Otis.”

Otis didn’t move.

The teacher beside Coach Kendrick looked nervous. She kept glancing between the grease on Otis’s shirt and the hallway behind us.

“Coach,” she said quietly, “perhaps we should take this to the office.”

“No,” Kendrick said.

His answer came too quickly.

He looked at me.

“Sam, you’re done for today. Go home.”

“I’m not leaving my glove.”

“You don’t have a choice.”

“I didn’t steal it.”

“We’ll discuss that with your mother.”

“My mother is working.”

“Then your grandmother.”

He knew exactly who could be called.

He knew my grandmother would come running if the school told her I was in trouble. He also knew she would be frightened by the word stolen.

Dalton knew it too.

That was why he smiled.

Otis turned toward the cafeteria doors.

“Come on, Sam.”

Coach Kendrick moved in front of him.

“You are not removing school property.”

Otis’s eyebrows rose.

“School property?”

“The glove belongs to the baseball program.”

“Then show me the inventory number.”

Coach Kendrick’s face tightened.

Dalton scoffed. “It’s an old catcher’s mitt. Who cares?”

“I care,” I said.

Nobody answered.

Otis looked at the teacher.

“Call Principal Alvarez.”

Coach Kendrick’s head snapped toward him.

“That won’t be necessary.”

“Then you won’t mind.”

The coach’s hand slipped into his jacket pocket.

I remembered my father telling me to watch hands.

Coach Kendrick kept one hand hidden whenever he lied.

He had done it in the cafeteria when he told everyone I had stolen the glove.

He did it now.

Otis noticed too.

“Bring the glove to my office,” Coach Kendrick said.

“No.”

“Otis.”

“No.”

The word echoed down the hallway.

Dalton’s smile disappeared.

Coach Kendrick lowered his voice.

“You’re an employee of this school.”

“And you’re a coach who just watched a boy’s personal property get dumped in a grease bin.”

“You are interfering with a disciplinary matter.”

“I’m protecting a child.”

“You’re protecting a story you don’t understand.”

Otis’s eyes sharpened.

For one second, something passed between them.

It wasn’t confusion.

It was recognition.

And fear.

Not Otis’s fear.

Coach Kendrick’s.

“Sam,” Otis said, “come with me.”

This time, Coach Kendrick let us pass.

But Dalton followed.

He stayed several steps behind, close enough for us to hear him.

“Don’t worry,” he called. “I’ll take good care of the position you abandoned.”

I stopped.

Otis kept walking, then looked back.

“Sam.”

Dalton leaned against a locker.

“You heard Coach. You’re out.”

“I didn’t abandon anything.”

“Sure you didn’t.”

“You threw away my glove.”

“You mean the equipment you stole?”

My hands curled into fists.

Otis came back and stood beside me.

Dalton looked at him.

“What? You’re going to cry about it?”

“No,” Otis said. “I’m going to remember it.”

Dalton laughed.

“You’re seventy-two. You forget where you put your keys.”

Up next