Part 2 of 9

“Take your hand off her.” A Santa stops a guardian dragging a child toward closing freight doors—then she spots a blue locket hidden beneath his beard.

35 min read · November 17, 2026

Curtis looked at her.

“No. But I can make sure people see it happen.”

Something in his voice made the store manager move closer.

Sylvia stood near the wall, gripping her white purse with both hands.

Curtis noticed her.

“You’re Daisy’s foster mother?”

Sylvia nodded.

“Licensed through which agency?”

She named the county partner that had registered us for the Christmas event.

“And you brought Daisy here for her scheduled appointment?”

“Yes.”

“Did you know she had the letter?”

Sylvia looked at Rosalind.

Curtis followed her gaze.

“Don’t look at your sister. Look at Daisy.”

Sylvia’s eyes filled.

“Yes,” she said. “I knew.”

“Did the letter belong to Rosalind?”

“No.”

Rosalind’s head snapped toward her.

“Sylvia.”

“It belonged to Daisy.”

The words came out thin and frightened, but they came out.

For one small moment, I felt my heart lift.

Then Sylvia grabbed the white purse again.

“She shouldn’t have brought it here,” she added. “It upsets her.”

My heart fell back down.

Curtis rose.

“Being upset is not the same as being unstable.”

“You don’t know what she’s like at home,” Rosalind said.

“No. I know what you’re like in public.”

The security guard coughed into his fist.

Rosalind’s face reddened.

Curtis pointed to my mitten.

“One fragment has the end of a name. Another has handwriting I recognize.”

“You recognize every dead woman’s handwriting?” Rosalind asked.

“No.”

His voice became quiet.

“I recognize this one.”

I stared at him.

“You knew Mama?”

“Yes.”

The word made my knees weak.

Adults had talked about Mama after she died.

Caseworkers had talked about medication and forms.

Foster parents had talked about how young she had been, how sick she had become, how difficult everything was.

Nobody ever said, I knew her.

“What was her name?” I asked.

“Rebecca Lawson.”

My breath caught.

“What did she call me?”

Rosalind rolled her eyes.

Curtis answered without looking away.

“Her crooked little star.”

I stared at the silver star on my mitten.

One point was longer than all the others. Mama had sewn it after I lost the matching mitten at a bus stop.

“How do you know that?”

“She told me.”

“When?”

Curtis looked toward the doorway leading back to the bright store.

Christmas music drifted through it.

“She was in the hospital. You were very young.”

I could hear Mama coughing in my memory.

I could see the water cup beside her bed and the purple shadows beneath her eyes.

“She was scared,” Curtis continued. “Not of dying. She was scared of leaving you behind.”

Rosalind stepped between us.

“That’s enough. You are frightening her.”

“No,” I said.

Rosalind turned.

I held my mitten tighter.

“I want him to talk.”

Her eyes narrowed.

Curtis reached into the pocket of his red coat and removed a folded appointment card.

My name was printed across the top.

DAISY LAWSON.

Below it was Sylvia’s name, the foster agency, and the time of my Santa photograph.

“I saw this before the event opened,” he said.

I looked from the card to his face.

“You knew I was coming?”

“I knew a child named Daisy Lawson was coming.”

“But you knew it was me.”

“I hoped it might be.”

Gary frowned.

“You searched the guest list?”

“The agency assigns each volunteer a schedule,” Curtis said. “That card was clipped beside my chair. I did not search anything.”

“Why would the name matter to you after all these years?” Sylvia asked.

Curtis folded the card carefully.

“Because I promised Rebecca I would make sure her daughter did not disappear into the system.”

No one spoke.

Even Rosalind went silent.

Curtis looked down at the red coat he was wearing.

“I retired from the bench years ago. Once Daisy entered foster care, her placement information was sealed. As it should have been.”

He looked at Gary.

“A retired judge cannot call an agency and demand a child’s address. I could not approach foster homes. I could not use old contacts to track a minor. That would have been unlawful and dangerous.”

“Then how did you expect to find her?” I asked.

He glanced toward the Santa display.

“I founded this Christmas event after I retired.”

Gary’s mouth tightened.

Curtis continued.

“It was meant to give children in care one day that did not feel like a court date, an intake interview, or another move. The county agencies register the children. They supervise the visits. Everything happens in public.”

“You dress up as Santa every year?” I asked.

A tired smile touched his face.

“Every year.”

“For me?”

“For many children.”

Then he knelt again.

“But every December, I looked at the appointment lists. I was never allowed to take private records or ask where children lived. I only looked at the names assigned to my own chair.”

“And today you saw mine.”

“Yes.”

“Why didn’t you say something?”

“Because a name isn’t proof.”

His eyes moved to the torn scraps.

“I needed to be certain before I put an old story on the shoulders of an eight-year-old girl.”

I pulled out the fragment with Norma’s name.

Up next