Part 2 of 9

“That’s garbage.” My stepmother said as my aunt held nine-year-old me over icy pavement—then the chief touched Dad’s star’s crooked point and silenced the ceremony.

36 min read · November 17, 2026

I looked down at it.

“He told me you had shaped it.”

My eyes burned.

Tamara folded her arms.

“Anyone could guess that after hearing Ben’s story.”

Rowland turned toward the Station 3 firefighters.

“You heard me say he left it like that before Ben told us he sanded it.”

Both men nodded.

So did several people close to the truck.

Tamara’s mouth tightened.

Rowland faced me again.

“I asked your dad if he wanted me to straighten it. We had better tools at the station. A belt sander would have fixed it in a few seconds.”

My stomach twisted around the word fixed.

Dad should have let him.

Maybe then Tamara wouldn’t have called it shabby.

Maybe she wouldn’t have broken it.

Maybe everyone wouldn’t be staring.

“But your father pulled the star away from me,” Rowland said. “He told me I wasn’t to touch that point.”

“Why?”

“He said you kept trying to make it perfect. He kept stopping you.”

I remembered Dad taking the sanding block from my hands.

That’s enough, Benny.

I had thought he was tired of watching me ruin it.

Rowland’s voice roughened.

“He said, ‘My boy put his hands on this. If I smooth out every mark he made, then it isn’t ours anymore.’”

I covered my mouth.

The red dust in my fist pressed deeper into my skin.

“He liked it?”

“He loved it.”

Tamara laughed once.

It was a small, ugly sound.

“This is absurd. Sawyer was trying to make a child feel better. Parents do that when children make mistakes.”

Rowland looked at her.

“He brought it to the station to show us.”

“He probably intended to throw it away afterward.”

“No.”

“You cannot know that.”

“I held it in my hands on the morning he died.”

Rowland lifted the crooked point.

“He told me this was the most important part.”

Something inside me cracked wider than the star had.

For two years, I had pictured Dad noticing every wrong thing I did.

The tilted point.

The paint I spilled in the garage.

The night I refused to finish dinner because he got called to the station.

The last morning, when I screamed at him.

I had built all those mistakes into one tall pile and placed Dad’s death on top.

The crooked point had always been proof.

Proof that my hands spoiled good things.

Proof that Dad left projects unfinished because of me.

Now the fire chief was saying Dad had carried my mistake to work like a treasure.

Tamara saw my face.

She stepped closer before Rowland could.

“Ben, don’t let him confuse you.”

“He isn’t.”

“Yes, he is. Chief Rowland feels guilty. Grief makes people remember things the way they wish they happened.”

Rowland flinched.

Tamara saw that too.

She pressed harder.

“Sawyer did not treasure every childish mistake. He had limits, like anyone else. You know that better than most.”

“Stop,” I whispered.

Her eyes stayed on mine.

“Tell the chief what you said to your father the last time you saw him.”

Rowland’s expression changed.

Tamara turned to the crowd.

“If everyone insists on turning this ceremony into a public examination of my family, then perhaps they should hear the whole truth.”

“Tamara,” Beverly said quietly.

Tamara ignored her.

“Ben has spent two years blaming himself. Encouraging this fantasy about a crooked decoration is not going to help him.”

I backed away.

Chief Rowland lowered the star.

“You don’t have to say anything, Ben.”

Tamara smiled sadly at the people watching.

That smile scared me more than her anger.

“He thinks his father left that morning because of him.”

“Be quiet,” Rowland said.

She raised her eyebrows.

“I’m his legal guardian. I’m also the person who has dealt with his episodes while all of you enjoyed remembering Sawyer as a hero.”

She pointed at the empty Station 7 chairs.

“Where were you when he woke up screaming? Where were you when he refused to go to school?”

Chief Rowland went pale.

“Tamara, stop.”

“Why? You want truth. Let’s have truth.”

She looked straight at me.

“Tell them your final words to your father.”

Every light in the square seemed too bright.

I could hear the tree branches clicking in the wind.

I could hear the ladder truck idling.

And beneath it all, I heard my own voice from that last morning.

High.

Angry.

Cruel.

Dad had been buttoning his uniform shirt near the front door.

He had promised pancakes, but the station called before the batter was mixed.

Again.

I had followed him through the house, shouting that he always left.

He knelt and tried to hug me.

I pushed him away.

“Ben?” Rowland said.

I stared at the crooked point.

“I told Dad he cared about the firehouse more than me.”

Tamara tilted her head.

“That isn’t exactly what you said.”

My chest hurt.

“I said, ‘You always choose them over me.’”

The words hung above the square.

Nobody moved.

I had never said them aloud since that morning.

Not to Grandma.

Not to my school counselor.

Not even when I was alone.

Dad had looked at me for a long time after I said them.

Then his radio had crackled.

He stood.

Up next