Part 7 of 9

“Who taught you that unfinished song?” Locked outside in Christmas snow with a bleeding palm, I sang—then the choir director saw my silver cross.

36 min read · November 16, 2026

If he remained silent, Nadine would finish what she had started.

She would erase my mother in the cathedral where she had once been loved.

The organist lowered his hands toward the keys.

Nadine positioned Norma at the center of the sanctuary.

I stood at the rear with my mother’s torn robe against my chest and her unfinished songbook hidden beneath the blanket.

Edwin took one step toward the altar.

Then he stopped.

The first chord of the closing hymn rolled through St. Mercy.

Chapter 4

The first chord of the closing hymn rolled through St. Mercy.

Edwin lifted the silver tuning fork.

He struck it once against the cathedral door.

The clear note cut through the organ.

It was not loud.

It did not need to be.

The organist took his hands from the keys.

The choir stopped breathing.

Edwin walked down the center aisle toward Nadine and Norma.

At eighty-four, he moved slowly.

No one mistook that for weakness.

“Mr. Aldridge,” Nadine said, still smiling, “we’ve already delayed the service long enough.”

“Yes,” he said. “We have delayed the truth long enough.”

The smile left her face.

A murmur passed through the pews.

Edwin stepped onto the sanctuary platform and faced the congregation.

“I apologize for interrupting our closing hymn. But this cathedral cannot award a scholarship under false pretenses.”

Nadine reached for Norma’s hand.

“This is a private family disagreement.”

“No,” Edwin said. “It became a cathedral matter when a forged invitation entered this building.”

The word struck the room like broken glass.

Forged.

Nadine’s hand tightened around Norma’s.

My father came to stand beside me.

Mrs. Keller lowered her head.

Edwin held up the two papers.

“This email confirmation was sent from the St. Mercy scholarship account four weeks ago. It names Audrey Whitaker as our Christmas Eve candidate.”

People turned toward the back of the choir.

Toward me.

I wanted to hide.

Instead, I stepped out from behind the last row.

The choir blanket remained around my shoulders. My bandaged hand held my mother’s torn robe against my chest.

Edwin raised the cream-colored letter.

“This document names Norma Whitaker. It bears what appears to be my signature and the seal of this cathedral.”

Nadine lifted her chin.

“Because it came from your office.”

“It did not.”

Her face hardened.

“You cannot possibly remember every paper you sign.”

“I remember the ones I do not sign.”

A few people laughed nervously.

Edwin did not.

“For twenty-seven years, I have signed scholarship invitations with my first initial and surname. E. Aldridge. Never my full name.”

He turned the letter toward the congregation.

“This signature reads Edwin Aldridge and contains a decorative line beneath it. I have never signed my name that way.”

Nadine looked toward Mrs. Keller.

Mrs. Keller took one step back.

Edwin continued.

“The seal is also false. The official St. Mercy seal includes the cathedral’s founding date beneath the bell. This one does not.”

He held my printed confirmation beside Norma’s invitation.

“And every genuine invitation contains my initials and an internal reference number. Audrey’s confirmation contains both. Norma’s letter contains neither.”

The cathedral had gone so quiet that I heard the candles crackle.

Nadine recovered quickly.

“Then the office made a mistake.”

“No.”

“Someone printed the wrong version.”

“No.”

“You’re accusing my daughter because Audrey performed some song in the snow.”

“I have accused Norma of nothing.”

Edwin looked toward my stepsister.

“Not yet.”

Norma’s shoulders folded inward.

The robe slipped down one arm.

Nadine pulled it back into place.

Edwin faced Mrs. Keller.

“You said Audrey’s name was not on the copy you saw.”

Mrs. Keller’s face was wet with tears.

“That’s right.”

“Tell us exactly what you saw.”

Nadine turned on her.

“You already answered this.”

Edwin’s voice sharpened.

“Let her speak.”

Mrs. Keller clasped her hands.

“Three weeks ago, Nadine came into the cathedral office. She said there had been an error with the scholarship mailing.”

“What kind of error?” Edwin asked.

“She said the invitation had gone to the wrong Whitaker girl.”

My heart pounded.

Mrs. Keller looked at me.

“She had an envelope with Audrey’s name on it.”

A gasp traveled through the pews.

My father closed his eyes.

Edwin did not move.

“What did Mrs. Whitaker ask you to do?”

“She asked me to print a new envelope with Norma’s name.”

“And did you?”

“Yes.”

“Did you alter the scholarship list?”

Mrs. Keller shook her head quickly.

“No. I didn’t have access.”

“Did you create this letter?”

“No.”

Nadine gave a bitter laugh.

“How convenient.”

Mrs. Keller flinched.

“I thought Nadine had permission. She said Audrey was emotionally unwell and had withdrawn.”

“I never withdrew,” I said.

Mrs. Keller looked at me.

“I know that now.”

Her voice broke.

“I should have called Mr. Aldridge. I should have checked. Instead, I let Nadine take the new envelope, and when she brought the finished letter back, I accepted it.”

“Why?” Edwin asked.

Mrs. Keller looked at Nadine.

“Because she told me the family had already suffered enough embarrassment.”

Nadine’s face turned flat.

That was the face I knew.

No tears.

No trembling smile.

No loving mother.

Just anger that someone had stopped obeying her.

“This is ridiculous,” she said. “A mislabeled envelope proves nothing. Audrey could still have created that email.”

Edwin held up my confirmation.

Up next