Part 1 of 9

With red marks on swollen ankles, I nearly fell into the lake carrying two coolers—then my mother-in-law threw my father’s keepsake shoe and a fisherman recognized it.

37 min read · November 16, 2026

Chapter 2

STORY CONTINUES

The fisherman came toward us with the shoe tucked inside his coat.

Water streamed from his rolled-up trousers. His gray beard was beaded with droplets, and the brass compass at his neck knocked softly against his chest with every step.

Marlene stood at the end of the dock, one hand gripping the rail.

For the first time that morning, she looked afraid.

“Get off this property,” she said.

The man kept walking.

I watched his eyes, not his clothes. He wasn’t looking at the Fairbanks dock or the people gathered around it.

He was looking at the shoe.

When he reached the ladder, he climbed out of the water and stood dripping on the boards.

The smell of lake mud rose around him.

He removed the shoe from inside his coat and held it in both hands. Water ran from the leather onto his knuckles.

“Who made this?” he asked again.

His voice was rough, but not loud.

I swallowed.

“My father.”

The man looked at me.

“What was his name?”

“Curtis Stafford.”

The change in his face was so sudden that I felt it in my own chest.

His fingers tightened around the tiny shoe.

“Curtis Stafford,” he repeated.

Marlene stepped forward.

“That’s enough.”

The man didn’t look at her.

“How long ago did he make it?”

“Two weeks before he died.”

“Died when?”

“Seven months ago.”

He lowered his gaze to the shoe.

The blue thread inside had darkened from the water, but I could still see the uneven stitches. They wandered along the leather in crooked little waves.

D.S.

Dean Stafford.

My father had stitched the initials so carefully, even though his hands were shaking too badly to keep the needle straight.

The fisherman traced one finger near the dark crescent-shaped mark.

He didn’t touch it.

Instead, he stared at it as if it had opened a door he had kept locked for years.

“He was still stitching with that hand?” he asked.

My mouth went dry.

“What do you mean?”

His eyes lifted to mine.

“Did his right hand tremble?”

I nodded slowly.

“Both hands, near the end. Mostly the right.”

“And did he have a scar across the heel of his palm?”

I looked down at the shoe.

The mark was faint now, just a dark crescent pressed into the leather near the heel. I had seen it a hundred times while Dad worked. Sometimes he would press the heel of his hand against the leather to hold it still, and the old scar would leave a stain.

“Yes,” I said. “A curved scar. He got it when he was young.”

The fisherman closed his eyes for one second.

Behind me, someone whispered, “How would he know that?”

Marlene answered sharply.

“He wouldn’t. He’s guessing.”

The fisherman opened his eyes.

He looked directly at her then.

The color drained from her face.

Not all at once. It faded in pieces, like water soaking into paper.

“You know me,” he said.

Marlene’s mouth tightened.

“I know plenty of men who fish this lake.”

“No, you know me.”

Dean moved closer to his mother.

“Do you know him?”

Marlene’s expression snapped back into place.

“He’s trespassing.”

“That isn’t what I asked.”

She ignored him and pointed toward the public water.

“You have no permission to come onto this dock. Leave now, or I’ll call the sheriff.”

The fisherman gave a humorless smile.

“You still threaten people when you don’t want to answer.”

Marlene flinched.

It was small.

A tightening around her eyes. A brief pull at the corner of her mouth.

But I saw it.

So did Dean.

The man turned back to me.

“I’m sorry,” he said. “I should have asked your name first.”

“Erin.”

“Erin what?”

“Stafford.”

His gaze moved over my face.

Then to my belly.

Then back to the shoe.

“Erin Stafford,” he said softly. “Curtis’s girl.”

No one spoke.

The lake lapped beneath the dock.

A gull cried somewhere beyond the boathouse.

I felt my hand move beneath my belly again.

“How did you know my father?”

The man looked toward the lake.

For a moment, he seemed to be listening to something far away.

“Your father and I worked the north shore together when we were boys. Before either of us had enough sense to stay out of trouble.”

My breath caught.

Dad had talked about people from those years, but never often. He had grown up poor in Pinewater, in a house with a tin roof and a wood stove that smoked when the wind changed.

He had told me about repairing boat motors for extra money and sleeping in a fishing shack when his mother’s house grew too crowded.

He had never mentioned this man.

“What’s your name?” I asked.

The fisherman hesitated.

“Willard Holloway.”

Marlene made a sound behind me.

Not a gasp.

Something harder.

A warning dragged through her teeth.

“Don’t,” she said.

Willard’s head turned slightly.

There it was again.

That look passing between them.

Recognition.

History.

And something that made Marlene look less like the woman who had controlled every room she entered and more like a child caught stealing.

“Willard Holloway,” I repeated.

He nodded.

“I run fishing trips out of the public marina. Independent guide. No Fairbanks money, no Fairbanks schedule, no Fairbanks permission.”

His eyes remained on Marlene.

“I do just fine without any of it.”

Marlene’s hand tightened on the rail.

Up next