Part 5 of 9

“Dead people don’t get presents.” My stepmother locked me outside in freezing snow after burning my mother’s photograph—then an old woman recognized the face and screamed a name.

36 min read · November 16, 2026

“Will they see it tonight?”

Bernice glanced toward the photograph resting on the mantel.

“They will.”

The church was already glowing when we arrived.

Snow covered the front steps, and candles shone through every stained-glass window. Families came through the doors carrying casseroles, wrapped gifts, and children in dress clothes.

The Angel Tree stood in the foyer.

Its paper stars trembled whenever the door opened.

I saw the empty place where the silver frame had been.

Colleen stood beside the tree.

She wore a black dress and the red velvet brooch. Her hair was curled neatly around her face. She held a stack of programs against her chest and smiled at every person who greeted her.

When she saw me, the smile widened.

“There’s my girl,” she called.

I stopped walking.

Bernice’s hand tightened around mine.

Colleen crossed the foyer.

“You look beautiful,” she said.

I moved closer to Bernice.

Colleen noticed.

Her smile remained, but her eyes hardened.

“I’ve missed you,” she told me.

It was a lie.

Her fingers touched the brooch.

“Pastor asked me to keep Lucy with me tonight,” she said to Bernice. “She’s had a difficult week.”

“I’ll be with her,” Bernice answered.

“Of course you will. But she is still my responsibility.”

“She is not leaving with you.”

Several people nearby turned their heads.

Colleen lowered her voice.

“Please don’t make this ugly in front of the children.”

“You made it ugly when you burned her mother’s photograph.”

Colleen’s face became pale and wounded.

“I have no idea what you’re talking about.”

She looked toward the sanctuary.

“Pastor?”

Pastor Goodwin stood near the pulpit, arranging his Christmas Eve service notes. He saw us and walked over.

Colleen hurried to meet him.

“Pastor, thank goodness. Bernice is upset again.”

Bernice’s hand did not leave mine.

“Upset about what?”

Colleen touched the red brooch.

“Lucy has been telling stories about the photograph. Bernice believes every word because she is grieving, too.”

Pastor Goodwin looked at me.

“Lucy, are you feeling all right?”

I nodded, though my stomach hurt.

Colleen moved closer to him.

“She needs to sit beside me during the service. I can keep her calm.”

Bernice stepped forward.

“No.”

Pastor Goodwin glanced at her.

“Bernice.”

“I am not handing Lucy back to the woman who locked her outside.”

Colleen’s eyes filled with tears.

“I was trying to keep her from running into the snow.”

“You locked the door while she begged you to open it.”

“She was having an episode.”

“She was holding the remains of a photograph you burned.”

The people nearby grew quiet.

Colleen faced them, her hand pressing over the brooch.

“I have been raising this child since Jeanette died,” she said. “I have done everything alone. Everything. And now, because Lucy is confused, I’m being accused of cruelty.”

Pastor Goodwin’s expression shifted.

He still looked uncertain.

That hurt more than I expected.

Bernice had told him the truth. I had told him the truth. He had seen my knees and my wet gloves.

Still, Colleen’s tears seemed to weigh more.

The choir began singing in the sanctuary.

The first notes drifted through the open doors.

Colleen reached for my arm.

“I’m taking you to your seat.”

I pulled away.

Her fingers closed around my wrist.

Not hard enough for everyone to see.

Hard enough for me to remember.

Bernice caught Colleen’s hand.

“Let her go.”

Colleen released me and immediately turned toward the families.

“See?” she said, her voice breaking. “She is afraid of me because Bernice has been filling her head with terrible things.”

Bernice’s face changed.

Not with fear.

With decision.

She took the photograph from her coat.

It was no longer inside the paper sleeve. She had placed it in a narrow wooden frame, pale and unfinished, with tiny brass corners.

She carried it to the pulpit.

Pastor Goodwin watched her.

“Bernice, what are you doing?”

“Putting the truth where everyone can see it.”

She set the photograph on the pulpit.

Mama’s face looked out over the church.

The burns were visible.

So was the paper star.

The choir stopped singing.

One by one, people turned in their seats.

Bernice walked to the front of the sanctuary.

I followed her.

Colleen remained near the foyer, one hand over the red brooch.

Pastor Goodwin picked up his service notes.

“Perhaps we should begin.”

Bernice looked at him.

“Not yet.”

The pastor hesitated.

Bernice faced the congregation.

“Many of you know this woman as Jeanette Yates.”

A murmur moved through the pews.

I had never heard anyone say Mama’s full name in church before.

“Some of you may remember her as a nurse at Saint Agnes Hospital,” Bernice continued. “Most of you did not know her at all.”

Colleen stepped forward.

“Bernice, this is not the time.”

Bernice did not look at her.

“I knew Jeanette twenty-four years ago. My husband, Harold, was dying of cancer. The hospital had stopped expecting him to wake up.”

The church grew completely still.

“She was his nurse. She was young. She had a little paper star pinned to her badge.”

Bernice placed one finger beside the star in the photograph.

“That is how I know her face.”

People leaned forward.

Up next