Part 6 of 9

“Dead people don’t get presents.” My stepmother locked me outside in freezing snow after burning my mother’s photograph—then an old woman recognized the face and screamed a name.

36 min read · November 16, 2026

“She pinned stars there for frightened patients,” Bernice said. “Harold was afraid of the dark. Jeanette made him believe he had a star beside him, even when the room went black.”

A woman in the front pew covered her mouth.

Bernice continued.

“She sat with him every night after her shift ended. She read him the newspaper. She played music on a little radio. When he could no longer speak, she spoke to him anyway.”

I felt my throat tighten.

“She also stayed with me,” Bernice said. “When I was too tired to stand. When I wanted to leave the hospital and never come back. When I thought I could not watch my husband die.”

Her voice broke.

“Jeanette found me in the elevator one night. I had made it as far as the doors. She sat down on the floor beside me. She held my hand until I could breathe. Then she walked me back to Harold’s room.”

No one moved.

“No one knew she did this,” Bernice said. “She never told anyone. She would have said she was only doing her job.”

Bernice looked at the photograph.

“She was not only doing her job. She was staying.”

I could barely see Mama through my tears.

“She stayed with Harold until he died,” Bernice said. “And when he was gone, she hugged me in the hallway and told me I had not failed him.”

Bernice wiped her cheek.

“I never saw Jeanette again. I didn’t know she had a daughter. I didn’t know she was gone. But I recognized her face tonight because of that paper star.”

Colleen gave a small, broken laugh.

“This is unbelievable.”

Bernice turned toward her.

“No. What is unbelievable is that you burned the last photograph of a woman who once saved my life.”

Several people looked at Colleen.

Her hand flew to the brooch.

“Jeanette abandoned Lucy,” she said. “She left her sick and helpless. I was the one who stayed.”

I flinched.

The sanctuary seemed to tilt.

Colleen’s eyes filled with tears.

“She made promises to this child, and then she died. Lucy has been angry ever since. She blames me because I’m still here.”

“That’s not true,” I whispered.

Colleen turned toward me.

“Sweetheart, you don’t understand what you’re saying.”

“She didn’t abandon me.”

“She did.”

“She loved me.”

“She loved herself more.”

Bernice moved toward me, but Colleen reached me first.

Her hand closed around my upper arm.

“Come on,” she said softly. “We’re leaving.”

I tried to pull back.

“Let go.”

“She’s overwhelmed,” Colleen announced. “I’m taking her home before she causes another scene.”

Pastor Goodwin remained beside the pulpit.

His service notes were still in his hand.

“Colleen, wait.”

Colleen looked at him with tearful patience.

“Pastor, please don’t make this harder. She is unstable, and Bernice is encouraging her.”

“I have not encouraged her to lie,” Bernice said.

“You have filled her head with stories about theft and abuse.”

“I have shown them what you burned.”

Colleen tightened her grip.

“Lucy is coming with me.”

I looked at Pastor Goodwin.

I wanted him to stop her.

I wanted him to remember the photograph, the ash on my mitten, the way Bernice had cried when she saw Mama’s face.

But he still looked caught between us.

Colleen pulled me toward the sanctuary doors.

“Tell them goodbye,” she whispered.

“I don’t want to go.”

Her fingers dug into my arm.

“Tell them.”

I stumbled beside her.

The congregation watched.

Some people looked away.

Some looked at Bernice.

A child near the front pew began to cry, and his mother pulled him close.

Colleen reached the doors.

“Lucy,” Pastor Goodwin said.

She stopped.

For one second, I thought he would come toward us.

Instead, he said, “Please don’t leave the building angry.”

Colleen turned her head.

“I’m not angry,” she said. “I’m protecting my child.”

Then she pulled the door open.

Cold air rushed into the sanctuary.

Bernice stepped between us and the exit.

“No,” she said.

Colleen’s face went still.

“What did you say?”

“I said you are not taking her out that door.”

The entire church seemed to hold its breath.

Colleen’s hand remained locked around my arm.

Pastor Goodwin lowered his Christmas service notes.

Bernice stood between me and the snow.

And above her shoulder, Mama’s photograph rested on the pulpit, her paper star shining beneath the sanctuary lights.

Chapter 4

“No,” Bernice said again.

Colleen’s fingers tightened around my arm.

For one terrible second, nobody moved.

Then Pastor Goodwin stepped away from the pulpit.

“Let go of Lucy.”

Colleen turned toward him, still wearing her tearful church face.

“Pastor, I’m taking my child home.”

“Let go of her.”

“She is frightened and confused.”

“I heard you,” he said. “Now you hear me.”

His voice was not loud, but it carried through the sanctuary.

Colleen’s hand remained locked around my arm.

Bernice moved closer. “Lucy, come to me.”

I pulled once.

Colleen’s grip tightened.

“She’s coming with me,” Colleen said.

Pastor Goodwin reached into his pocket and took out his phone.

“If you do not release her, I will call the police.”

Colleen stared at him.

“You wouldn’t.”

“I will.”

Her hand flew to the red velvet brooch.

“I have been this child’s only parent.”

Up next