Part 2 of 9

“Don’t.” A 79-year-old organist reached into a nearly full rain barrel for his wife’s hymnbook after a church leader banished him—then a gospel legend ran.

35 min read · November 16, 2026

For forty years, I had let people call it a mystery. I had watched singers record the hymn. I had heard it at funerals and weddings. I had played it myself while Maureen sat in the third pew with her head bowed.

Whenever anyone asked where it came from, I said what she had told me to say.

Some songs arrive where they are needed.

Nothing more.

Never her name.

“Laurel,” I said, “please don’t ask me that.”

She stared at me.

“You know.”

“I didn’t say that.”

“You didn’t have to.”

Rhonda stepped forward.

“This is absurd.”

Laurel ignored her.

“Did Maureen know my name?”

I looked toward the empty third pew.

My wife had sat on the aisle. Always on the aisle, so she could slip out if someone needed help in the nursery or the kitchen.

“Mr. Aldridge.”

I closed my eyes.

Maureen’s voice came back to me as clearly as if she stood at my shoulder.

Promise me, Edwin.

Not now. Not later.

Let the song do what it was meant to do.

I opened my eyes.

“I made my wife a promise.”

Laurel drew a sharp breath.

There it was.

Not an answer, but close enough to wound us both.

“What promise?”

“I can’t tell you.”

“You mean you won’t.”

“Yes.”

Her face crumpled for half a second.

Then she gathered herself.

“I have spent forty years wanting to say thank you.”

“I know.”

The words escaped before I could stop them.

Laurel took my wrist.

“You know?”

I stared at her hand on my sleeve.

She loosened her grip but did not let go.

“You knew someone was looking?”

I said nothing.

The leather case hung against her coat between us.

“You knew I was looking for the woman who wrote that letter,” she said.

“I knew there had been questions.”

“Questions?”

Her voice rose.

“I put notices in gospel magazines. I asked pastors from Georgia to California. I had people send me boxes of old choir programs and church bulletins. I followed every rumor.”

She looked down at Maureen’s ruined book.

“And you call those questions?”

“I had promised her.”

“Why would she ask you to hide her?”

I looked at the sentence.

Never say my name.

“Because being known frightened her more than being forgotten.”

Laurel’s anger fell away.

What remained was grief.

“She thought I would make a spectacle of her?”

“No.”

“Then what?”

“I’ve said too much already.”

Laurel let go of my wrist.

For a moment, neither of us spoke.

The younger musician quietly rose from the bench. He picked up his black folder and moved away from the organ.

Rhonda noticed.

“Sit back down,” she ordered.

He looked at me.

Then at the water dripping from the hymnbook.

“I think I should wait.”

“You were hired to play.”

“I was asked to play.”

“Then play.”

Laurel turned.

“No one is playing while we sort this out.”

Rhonda’s mouth opened.

The young man took another step away.

Rhonda touched her useless headset.

“The livestream is still running.”

“Then turn it off,” Laurel said.

“We have hundreds of people watching.”

“Good. They can see what happened.”

Curtis came down from the pulpit.

His thumb rubbed the same blank place on his tie.

“Ms. Sinclair, perhaps we could discuss this privately.”

Laurel faced him.

“Was throwing the book away private?”

Curtis stopped.

“Of course not.”

“Was removing Mr. Aldridge from the organ private?”

“No, but—”

“Was calling him confused private?”

Curtis glanced toward Rhonda.

She answered for him.

“We made a necessary decision.”

“You humiliated a seventy-nine-year-old man in the church where he has served for fifty years.”

“He was becoming disruptive.”

“I saw him ask for his property.”

“He refused to cooperate with the program.”

“You threw his dead wife’s book into a barrel.”

Rhonda lifted her chin.

“The material in that book is unverified.”

Irene moved then.

Only one step, but I saw it.

Her arms tightened around the anniversary ledger.

Laurel saw it too.

“What do you have there?” she asked.

Irene looked down.

“The church’s original anniversary ledger.”

“Does it mention Maureen?”

Irene hesitated.

Rhonda’s head snapped toward her.

“This is not the time to drag through old records.”

Laurel waited.

Irene ran one hand over the ledger’s cover.

“I believe it does.”

“What does it say?”

“I don’t know exactly.”

“You’ve been carrying it all morning.”

“I haven’t read every page.”

Rhonda walked toward her.

“The ledger is for the historical presentation, Irene. We are already behind schedule.”

Irene held it more tightly.

“I know.”

“Then put it where it belongs.”

Irene did not move.

Rhonda’s smile returned, thin and cold.

“The board approved today’s program.”

Irene looked at her.

“You told me the board had approved Edwin’s replacement.”

“It did.”

“You told me Curtis had spoken with him.”

Curtis stopped smoothing his tie.

Rhonda’s eyes sharpened.

“This is hardly the place.”

Irene looked toward me.

“Edwin, did Curtis speak with you before this morning?”

“No.”

Curtis lowered his head.

Something passed through Irene’s face.

Shame, perhaps.

Or anger at realizing she had lent her name to a lie.

“I see,” she said.

Rhonda strode back to the organ.

“Enough.”

She reached for the hymnbook.

Up next