Part 3 of 9

“Don’t.” A 79-year-old organist reached into a nearly full rain barrel for his wife’s hymnbook after a church leader banished him—then a gospel legend ran.

35 min read · November 16, 2026

Laurel put her hand over it.

“No.”

“This belongs to the church.”

“It belongs to Mr. Aldridge.”

“It contains material copied from the church’s collection.”

I felt heat rise into my face.

“Maureen copied nothing.”

Rhonda looked at the congregation as if inviting them to witness my confusion.

“The famous hymn in question existed long before Maureen started scribbling in margins. Edwin is grieving. He sees what he wants to see.”

Laurel’s hand flattened against the wet page.

“What hymn in question?”

Rhonda blinked.

For the first time, she had spoken too far.

Laurel stepped closer.

“I did not name a hymn.”

Rhonda recovered quickly.

“Everyone knows why you’re here.”

Yes.

They did.

The centennial committee had invited Laurel because our choir had given her signature hymn its first public performance. The old choir program had been found years later in the church archives, dated months before Laurel’s first recording.

The program had listed the song.

It had not listed a writer.

That absence had become part of the story.

An unknown source.

An anonymous gift.

A mystery wrapped neatly enough for anniversary brochures.

Laurel looked from Rhonda to me.

“The letter I received led me to that hymn,” she said. “This church’s choir was the first to sing it before a congregation. That is why I accepted your invitation.”

Her voice grew softer.

“I thought I was coming home to the place that first gave the song breath.”

“You are,” Curtis said quickly.

Laurel looked around the sanctuary.

“Am I?”

No one answered.

Rhonda seized the edge of the wet page.

Laurel held on.

“Let go,” Laurel said.

Rhonda pulled.

The paper tore with a soft, terrible sound.

I lunged forward.

A ragged strip came away in Rhonda’s hand.

The remaining page curled against the music rack.

Laurel stared at the tear.

So did everyone else.

Rhonda looked at the strip she had ripped free. Maureen’s handwriting crossed it in wavering lines.

For one second, fear entered Rhonda’s eyes.

Then she crushed the paper in her fist.

“This proves nothing.”

I took a step toward her.

My knees did not hurt anymore.

“Give that back.”

“It’s damaged.”

“You damaged it.”

“It fell into the barrel.”

“You put it there.”

Rhonda turned toward Curtis.

“Tell them.”

He looked at her.

“Tell them what?”

“That none of this will be mentioned during the program.”

Laurel gave a disbelieving laugh.

“You cannot be serious.”

Rhonda’s voice hardened.

“This is our church’s centennial, Ms. Sinclair. Not an investigation into an old woman’s scribbles.”

I heard people gasp then.

At last.

Not when she called me confused.

Not when she took my bench.

Not when Maureen’s book struck the water.

But they heard that.

An old woman’s scribbles.

Mrs. Danner stood in the first pew with one hand over her mouth.

The choir director shook his head.

Even the camera operator stepped away from his machine.

Curtis looked at Rhonda as if he had finally seen the cliff beneath his feet.

She pointed toward the pulpit.

“Make the announcement.”

“Rhonda—”

“Now.”

He obeyed.

Each step he took sounded heavy.

He stood behind the pulpit and adjusted the microphone. It gave a small squeal.

The livestream camera swung toward him.

Curtis smoothed his tie.

“Friends,” he began, “we’ve had an unexpected delay.”

Laurel stood beside the organ, one hand protecting the open hymnbook.

Irene held the ledger like a shield.

Rhonda remained in the aisle with the torn piece of Maureen’s page clenched in her fist.

Curtis cleared his throat.

“The book involved in this unfortunate misunderstanding contains personal, unverified writings. Out of respect for the anniversary service, it will not be discussed as part of today’s program.”

A low murmur rolled across the sanctuary.

I looked at him.

He saw me.

For half a heartbeat, I thought he might stop.

Then Rhonda gave him a small nod.

Curtis continued.

“We ask everyone to return to their seats so our celebration may proceed in a spirit of unity.”

Unity.

People like Curtis loved that word when they meant surrender.

Laurel closed Maureen’s hymnbook carefully.

Water squeezed from its swollen pages.

“You’re asking him to sit down and accept this,” she said.

Curtis stepped away from the microphone.

“I’m asking everyone to help us avoid further embarrassment.”

“Whose embarrassment?”

His eyes moved toward Rhonda.

That was answer enough.

Laurel lifted the hymnbook from the rack and held it against her coat.

Rhonda walked to the guest microphone.

“Laurel, we have a full sanctuary and a national audience waiting to hear you sing.”

“They can wait.”

“We have promoted this appearance for months.”

“I didn’t come here for your promotion.”

“You agreed to perform.”

“I agreed to honor the song’s first home.”

“And you will.”

Laurel looked at the torn page in Rhonda’s hand.

“Not while you treat its history like trash.”

Rhonda’s cheeks flushed.

“You are drawing conclusions from handwriting in a waterlogged scrapbook.”

“Hymnbook,” I said.

She ignored me.

Laurel touched the leather case beneath her scarf.

“I know what I recognize.”

“And I know what this service needs.”

Rhonda took the microphone from its stand.

She tapped it twice.

The sound boomed through the sanctuary.

Up next