Part 5 of 10

“Give him to me.” My mother-in-law carried my two-day-old son into a blizzard while I stumbled barefoot, until a snowplow driver recognized my quilt’s red cross.

41 min read · November 15, 2026

Maybe he had known from the beginning.

“Did you know she took them?” I asked.

His silence answered me again.

A woman behind him whispered, “The roads are closed. Maybe Holly shouldn’t have come out.”

“I didn’t have a choice,” I said.

Brenda gave Earl a small bounce.

His crying had not stopped.

It had grown rough and breathless, the way it did when he was too tired to cry properly.

“Please,” I said. “Give him to me.”

Brenda looked down at him.

“He’s upset because you’re upsetting everyone.”

“No. He’s upset because he’s cold and hungry.”

“He was fed before we left.”

“You don’t know that.”

“I was there.”

“You took him from my arms.”

“I took him because you were exhausted.”

“You took him because you wanted him in your pageant.”

Brenda’s gold manger pin caught the light as she lifted her chin.

“This pageant is not about me.”

Every person in the church looked at the pin.

It was shaped like a tiny stable, with a gold star above the roof.

She wore it every Christmas.

She had worn it to the hospital when Earl was born, even though the hospital was closed to visitors and she had not been allowed past the entrance.

She had worn it at the cabin while demanding that my son be named Gabriel.

Now she wore it beneath the wooden star, with Earl dressed as a prop in her arms.

“You arranged this before I gave birth,” I said.

Her smile vanished.

“You have been ungrateful from the beginning.”

The room went still.

Brenda seemed to realize she had spoken too plainly.

She turned back to the congregation.

“I only wanted to give everyone something beautiful tonight.”

“You wanted everyone to praise you.”

“Holly,” Gordon warned.

“No,” I said.

The word shook, but I did not take it back.

“No more warnings. No more telling me to be quiet so your mother can lie.”

Gordon’s face tightened.

“She is still my mother.”

“And I am your wife.”

He looked away.

Brenda shifted Earl toward the volunteers.

“Can someone please take him to the back room? He needs to be changed before the pageant begins.”

Marjorie did not move.

The other volunteer, a young woman named Celia, stepped forward uncertainly.

She wore a paper crown crooked over her dark hair.

“I can take him,” she said.

“No,” I said.

Brenda’s eyes snapped to mine.

“You don’t get to give orders here.”

“He is my son.”

“He is the baby Jesus for tonight’s pageant.”

“He is two days old.”

“That is why he needs someone capable of handling him.”

Celia stopped with one hand half-raised.

I could see the costume now.

The white fabric wrapped around Earl’s middle was not a blanket. It was rough muslin, tied with gold cord. Someone had pinned a tiny paper crown to the manger beside him. The crown had been cut from glittered poster board.

His cheeks were red.

One of his hands had worked free, and his fingers trembled in the cold air.

“Take that off him,” I said.

Brenda covered his hand with her own.

“He’s fine.”

“He’s freezing.”

“He has been in the church for ten minutes.”

“He was outside in a storm before that.”

The congregation stirred.

Some faces changed.

Not enough.

Brenda saw the opening and closed it quickly.

“She is exaggerating,” she said. “I kept him wrapped the whole way.”

“The quilt was in the snow.”

That came from Floyd.

His voice was low, but it carried.

Every head turned toward him.

Brenda looked him up and down.

His canvas coat was wet. Snow clung to his boots. His cheeks were red from the wind.

“And you are?”

“Floyd Ingram.”

A few people in the back recognized him.

An older man raised his eyebrows.

“Floyd Ingram? County plows?”

“Retired,” Floyd said.

Brenda’s smile returned, polished and cold.

“Mr. Ingram, this is a family matter.”

“No,” he said. “It’s a newborn.”

The church became so quiet I could hear the furnace clicking beneath the floor.

Brenda’s eyes narrowed.

“You don’t know Holly.”

“I know what she looked like when I found her.”

“That does not give you the right to interfere.”

“It gives me the right to say a baby shouldn’t be carried into a blizzard without his mother.”

A few people murmured agreement.

Brenda turned to Gordon.

“Please handle this.”

Gordon looked at Floyd.

Then at me.

Then at Brenda.

His hands curled into fists at his sides.

“Floyd,” he said, “you should leave.”

The old man stared at him.

“Your wife came out of that storm barefoot.”

“I know.”

“She was bleeding through her nightclothes.”

My hand went instinctively to my abdomen.

A woman gasped.

Brenda’s face hardened.

“She was not bleeding.”

Floyd looked at me.

I had not noticed the dark mark until then.

My slippers were soaked with snow and mud, but a thin red stain had appeared near the hem of my nightgown.

It was small.

Not dramatic.

Just enough to show how far I had pushed my body because no one else was bringing my baby back.

Gordon saw it too.

His eyes dropped.

Brenda stepped between him and the sight.

“She is trying to make everyone afraid.”

“I’m not trying to make anyone afraid,” I said. “I am asking for my son.”

Earl cried again.

His face turned toward me.

I took one step forward.

Brenda immediately stepped back.

Up next