Part 6 of 10

“Give him to me.” My mother-in-law carried my two-day-old son into a blizzard while I stumbled barefoot, until a snowplow driver recognized my quilt’s red cross.

41 min read · November 15, 2026

The movement was instinctive.

She knew I would take him if I got close enough.

Gordon moved with her.

He placed one hand against my shoulder.

“Don’t.”

I looked down at his fingers.

“Move.”

“Holly, please.”

“Move.”

“You’re making a scene.”

“She made the scene.”

“It’s Christmas Eve.”

“My baby is in a costume beneath a star.”

“He’s safe.”

“Then give him to me.”

Gordon’s hand fell away.

For half a second, hope rose in me.

Then Brenda spoke.

“Gordon, don’t let her frighten him.”

He turned toward me again.

The hope died.

“I’m not going to let you grab him,” he said.

I stared at him.

“You think I’m going to hurt my own baby?”

“No.”

“Then what are you afraid of?”

He looked at his mother.

That was the answer.

Brenda reached out and touched his arm.

The gesture was gentle enough to appear loving.

Her fingers rested there like a claim.

“You have done everything you can,” she told him. “Let the people who came to help handle this.”

I could not stop looking at her hand on his sleeve.

She had done that all his life.

Held on.

Spoken for him.

Decided when he was allowed to disagree.

And he had called it love because the other word frightened him.

Gordon turned to me.

“She is still my mother.”

This time, his voice was almost pleading.

As if he wanted me to understand that the words excused everything.

As if being his mother made her more important than being Earl’s mother.

I felt something inside me go quiet.

Not calm.

Something colder.

“Then you should have married her,” I said.

His face went white.

Brenda’s hand fell from his arm.

A sharp breath moved through the pews.

“Holly,” Gordon whispered.

“No. You don’t get to stand between me and my child because you’re afraid of hurting her feelings.”

“I am not afraid.”

“You followed her here.”

“I came to protect you.”

“You came to protect the family’s reputation.”

“That isn’t fair.”

“Neither was leaving me alone in that cabin.”

He flinched.

For the first time, I saw the shame beneath his fear.

It did not make me forgive him.

Not yet.

Brenda turned away from us and raised her voice.

“Friends, I’m sorry you’re witnessing this.”

Several people looked toward her.

She had found her place again.

The center of the room.

The voice that explained what everyone else should feel.

“I had hoped tonight would bring us together,” she continued. “After a difficult year, I thought a child could remind us what Christmas means.”

Earl cried beneath the white cloth.

Brenda lifted him higher.

His head wobbled against her shoulder.

My body reacted before my mind did.

I moved toward the platform.

Floyd caught my elbow.

“Not yet,” he murmured.

I looked at him.

“Why not?”

“Because she wants you to rush.”

“She has my baby.”

“And she wants them to see you lose control.”

I looked around the church.

At the faces watching me.

At the people who had already begun to believe Brenda’s version.

Floyd leaned closer.

“Make them watch him,” he said.

I understood what he meant.

Earl was the truth.

Not Brenda’s calm voice.

Not Gordon’s silence.

Not the gold pin or the wooden star.

Earl.

His red face.

His trembling hand.

The cry that would not stop.

I stood still.

Brenda began speaking about the pageant.

She told them the children had practiced for weeks. She thanked the volunteers. She thanked the pastor, who was standing near the side aisle with an expression of growing discomfort.

Then she thanked Gordon.

“For standing by his family.”

Gordon lowered his head.

The congregation applauded.

The sound made my stomach turn.

Brenda’s eyes found mine over the applause.

Her smile was warm for everyone else.

Her voice dropped so low that only I could hear.

“You should have stayed in the cabin.”

I held the quilt tighter around my shoulders.

“You should have left my baby there.”

“You don’t deserve to make this night about your resentment.”

“You took him to punish me.”

“I took him because you don’t know how to be part of a family.”

“You mean your family.”

“You married into it.”

“I gave birth to my own.”

Her smile remained fixed.

But her eyes were empty.

“You think that gives you power.”

“It gives me the right to take my son back.”

“Not if you’re unstable.”

Behind her, Earl’s crying broke into a ragged gasp.

I took another step.

Brenda raised one hand.

Celia moved in front of the manger.

Not because she wanted to.

Because Brenda had told her to.

“Please,” Celia said, “just wait until the pageant is over.”

I stared at her.

“Did you see me give permission?”

Celia’s mouth opened.

No words came out.

“Did you hear me say Brenda could take him?”

She looked toward Marjorie.

Marjorie shook her head faintly.

Brenda’s voice cut through the room.

“They were told you had agreed.”

“I did not agree.”

“You were confused.”

“I was holding him.”

“You were exhausted.”

“I said no.”

Celia looked down at the baby costume.

The gold cord had slipped beneath Earl’s arm.

His skin was flushed and damp.

“Brenda,” she said quietly, “maybe we should take him out of that.”

Brenda turned on her.

“Are you questioning me now?”

“No, I just—”

“You helped prepare the costume.”

“I didn’t know Holly hadn’t agreed.”

Brenda’s face changed.

Up next