Part 1 of 10

"Mom made it," my husband lied as his pregnant wife was shoved toward the steps until an 80-year-old judge grabbed his mother’s wrist to expose what she hid.

41 min read · November 16, 2026

Chapter 2

STORY CONTINUES

The volunteer’s knife hovered over the pie.

Loretta still had one hand trapped in Alvin Hastings’s grip and the torn recipe card clutched in the other.

“Cut it,” Alvin said.

The volunteer looked from him to Loretta.

“Mr. Hastings, are you sure?”

“I am the head judge.”

His voice was quiet, but it carried across the tent.

The volunteer pressed the knife into the center of the crust.

The pie gave way with a soft crack.

Steam rose from the filling.

A warm, buttery smell drifted through the crowd.

Peaches.

Cinnamon.

And something deeper.

Something almost like summer preserves left too long in a copper pot.

My stomach tightened.

I knew that smell.

I had smelled it every time Mom made this pie.

Loretta smelled it, too.

Her eyes darted toward the knife.

Alvin noticed.

He released her wrist only after the volunteer lifted out a thick slice.

The filling stretched in glossy strands between the crust and the plate.

It was not runny.

It did not collapse into a puddle the way ordinary peach pie filling did.

The peaches held together beneath the lattice, surrounded by a dark golden glaze.

Alvin leaned over the plate.

“What did you put in this?” he asked.

Loretta rubbed her wrist.

“Peaches.”

“That is not what I asked.”

“Sugar. Cinnamon. A little nutmeg.”

“A little nutmeg,” Alvin repeated.

“Yes.”

“And what else?”

Loretta gave a brittle laugh.

“Are you going to interrogate every contestant like this?”

“Only the ones who cannot answer a simple question.”

A few people in the crowd murmured.

Loretta’s face reddened.

She had expected applause, not questions.

She had expected the ribbon to settle over her name like a crown.

Instead, an eighty-year-old judge was studying her pie as if it were evidence.

Alvin picked up his fork again.

He scraped a small amount of filling from the cut edge and tasted it.

He closed his eyes.

I knew that look.

Mom used to make it when tasting a sauce that needed one more pinch of salt.

Alvin opened his eyes.

“Cinnamon is not the secret ingredient.”

Loretta crossed her arms.

“There is no secret ingredient.”

“There is in this pie.”

“It’s a peach pie, Alvin. Not a state secret.”

The crowd gave a nervous laugh.

Loretta smiled as if she had won something.

Alvin did not smile back.

He set down the fork.

“Did you cook the peach preserves separately?”

The laughter stopped.

Loretta stared at him.

“What preserves?”

“The peach preserves.”

“I don’t know what you mean.”

“Yes, you do.”

“I used fresh peaches.”

“Of course you used fresh peaches. Irene always did.”

The name moved through me like a hand closing around my heart.

Irene.

Mom.

Alvin had said her name without hesitation, as if she were standing beside him.

Loretta looked toward the crowd.

“She’s confused,” she said. “This is what I’ve been trying to explain. Marcia is upset because she wanted attention today.”

I stepped forward.

“I’m not confused.”

The young volunteer immediately put out a hand.

“Ma’am, please stay back from the table.”

“I made that pie.”

“Let the judge finish.”

“I know what’s in it.”

Loretta whipped around.

“You know what’s in it because you tampered with it.”

The accusation struck so sharply that even the volunteer looked startled.

“What?”

“She followed me here,” Loretta said. “She was angry that I entered. She must have added something after I baked it.”

“That’s a lie.”

“She had access to the pie.”

“It was in my kitchen.”

“Exactly.”

Loretta turned toward the judges.

“She could have changed the filling this morning and then staged this whole scene.”

A man near the front frowned.

“She says it came from her house.”

Loretta lifted her chin.

“Marcia has been trying to undermine me for years.”

I looked at Wade.

He had not moved.

His volunteer badge gleamed beneath the fairground lights.

The words printed across it read STAFF.

He looked like a man with authority.

He looked like a man who could stop this.

“Tell them,” I said.

He swallowed.

“Marcia…”

“Tell them she didn’t bake it.”

His face tightened.

Loretta’s eyes slid toward him.

That was all it took.

He looked away.

My hand moved to my belly.

The baby shifted beneath my palm, gentle but insistent.

I thought of the first time Mom had let me stir the peach filling.

I had been ten.

She had placed a wooden spoon in my hand and stood behind me, her arms folded around my shoulders.

“Slowly,” she had said. “Don’t bruise the fruit.”

“I’m stirring.”

“You’re fighting it.”

“I’m not.”

“You are. Peaches are soft. You can’t order them around.”

She had smiled when I frowned.

Then she had pulled a small saucepan from the stove.

Inside was a thick, amber mixture that looked nothing like the sliced peaches in the bowl.

“What’s that?”

“The part people taste but don’t identify.”

She had cooked peach preserves separately until they darkened and thickened.

Then she had let them cool.

Only after the mixture stopped steaming did she fold it into the fresh peaches.

“If you add it hot,” Mom had explained, “the fruit turns to mush.”

“Why not mix it in with everything else?”

“Because the filling needs two kinds of sweetness. One you notice. One you remember.”

I had not understood then.

I understood now.

Alvin pointed to the slice on the plate.

Up next