Part 2 of 10

"Mom made it," my husband lied as his pregnant wife was shoved toward the steps until an 80-year-old judge grabbed his mother’s wrist to expose what she hid.

41 min read · November 16, 2026

“The preserves were cooked separately,” he said. “Reduced until the water was gone. Then cooled and folded into the fresh peaches before the flour was added.”

Loretta’s mouth tightened.

“That’s one way to make a pie.”

“No,” Alvin said. “That is Irene Crawford’s way to make this pie.”

The crowd shifted.

Someone behind me whispered, “Irene’s daughter made those for the veterans’ supper.”

Another voice answered, “She won the fair in ’89.”

Loretta’s eyes flashed toward them.

“Anyone can cook preserves.”

“Not this way,” Alvin said.

He picked up the fork and lifted a piece of peach.

“See the edges? The fruit is still intact. The glaze is concentrated around it, not washed through the whole filling. That only happens when the preserves are cooked down separately and cooled before folding.”

He looked at Loretta.

“Who taught you that?”

She hesitated.

Only for a moment.

But everyone saw it.

“I’ve been baking for forty years,” she said.

“That wasn’t my question.”

“I know how to make peach pie.”

“Then tell us the final step.”

Loretta gave a little shrug.

“You put it in the oven.”

A few people laughed.

This time, it was not with her.

Alvin’s expression hardened.

“Before the oven.”

Loretta’s gaze fell to the pie.

“Nothing unusual.”

“Do you cool the preserves before folding them into the fruit?”

She said nothing.

“Do you add them after the peaches have been tossed with sugar?”

“I told you. I use my own method.”

“Your own method does not explain this filling.”

“Maybe the fruit was different.”

“The peaches are not the issue.”

“Maybe someone helped me.”

“Who?”

Loretta’s head snapped up.

She looked straight at me.

“There. She helped me.”

The crowd went silent again.

“She was in my kitchen,” Loretta said. “She must have altered the filling while I was preparing the crust.”

I stared at her.

“You took the pie after I baked it.”

“No one saw that.”

“Wade did.”

Wade’s face went pale.

Loretta turned to him.

“Did you see me take anything?”

His lips parted.

The fair music continued somewhere beyond the tent. A bell rang near the livestock barn. Children shouted at a game booth.

But at the judging table, everything waited for his answer.

I could see the memory in his face.

His mother walking through the back door.

The covered pie in her hands.

His eyes following her.

His voice telling me to let it go.

“Wade,” I said.

He looked at me.

For one second, I thought he might finally step away from his mother.

Then Loretta spoke softly.

“Be careful.”

It was not a request.

It was a warning.

Wade lowered his eyes.

“I didn’t see anything,” he said.

The lie settled over the table like dust.

Something inside me went cold.

Loretta turned back to Alvin.

“There,” she said. “You heard him.”

Alvin’s gaze remained on Wade.

“No,” he said. “I heard a man afraid of his mother.”

Wade flinched.

Loretta’s face twisted.

“Excuse me?”

“You heard me.”

“I will not be insulted by a judge who has already decided against me.”

“I have decided nothing.”

“You’re taking her side.”

“I am asking you to identify your own recipe.”

“I already did.”

“You named cinnamon.”

“That’s what’s in it.”

Alvin cut another piece of filling and held it up.

“Cinnamon is in nearly every peach pie entered today. It is not what gives this one its depth.”

“Maybe my peaches are sweeter.”

“Maybe.”

“Maybe I have a better hand with fruit than you do.”

“Then tell me the proportion.”

Loretta’s eyes narrowed.

“What proportion?”

“How much preserve did you reduce?”

“I don’t measure.”

“How long did you cook it?”

“I cook by feel.”

“What did you cool it in?”

She stared at him.

Alvin leaned closer.

“What temperature was the preserve before you folded it into the peaches?”

Loretta’s silence grew longer.

A woman near the front folded her arms.

Another took out her phone.

The sight of it made Loretta furious.

“Are you recording me?”

The woman lowered the phone halfway.

“I’m listening.”

“You have no right to turn this into a spectacle.”

Loretta swept her arm toward the crowd.

“You all know me. I’ve baked for this county for decades. I’ve donated pies to every church supper and bake sale.”

“Not this pie,” Alvin said.

Her eyes burned.

“You don’t know what you’re talking about.”

“I know exactly what I’m talking about.”

“No, you know a dead woman’s recipe and you want to make her daughter feel better.”

The words struck the air from my lungs.

Alvin went very still.

Loretta saw the reaction and pressed harder.

“Irene was talented. Fine. Everyone knows that. But she is gone. Her daughter is standing here trying to use grief as a shortcut to a blue ribbon.”

My fingers curled around the edge of my dress.

Mom was gone.

That was true.

But her hands were in that pie.

Her patience.

Her little peach flower.

The way she had taught me to cool the preserves before folding them in.

Loretta could call me jealous.

She could call me unstable.

She could lie about Wade.

But she could not make Mom disappear a second time.

“I didn’t enter this pie to win,” I said.

Loretta laughed.

“Of course you did.”

“I entered it because I promised my mother I would.”

“You promised a dead woman?”

“Yes.”

The word came out stronger than I expected.

The crowd quieted.

Up next