Part 1 of 9

“Who taught you that unfinished song?” Locked outside in Christmas snow with a bleeding palm, I sang—then the choir director saw my silver cross.

36 min read · November 16, 2026

Chapter 2

STORY CONTINUES

Edwin did not ask Nadine’s permission.

He took off his coat, wrapped it around my shoulders, and guided me past her.

Snow melted from my hair onto the cathedral floor.

“She needs warmth,” he said. “And someone needs to see to that hand.”

Only then did I look at my palm.

A thin cut ran beneath my thumb where the ice had caught me. Blood had mixed with melting snow and stained the torn robe.

Nadine rushed forward.

Her face had changed again.

The satisfied woman who had watched me fall was gone. In her place stood a frightened, loving stepmother.

“Oh, Audrey.”

She reached for me.

I stepped behind Edwin.

Her hand stopped in the air.

“I’ve been so worried,” she said, loudly enough for the choir to hear. “She ran outside before we could stop her.”

“You locked the door,” I said.

A few people looked toward the brass key still in Edwin’s hand.

Nadine’s smile trembled.

“For everyone’s safety.”

“You pushed me.”

“I tried to keep you from hurting yourself.”

“You tore my mother’s robe.”

Nadine pressed one hand to her chest.

“Mr. Aldridge, you must understand. Audrey has been confused since Irene passed. She took Norma’s robe, and when we tried to get it back, she ripped it.”

Norma stood near the sanctuary steps wearing the other half of the robe.

Both sleeves were rolled twice.

The split cross hung crookedly over her heart.

She would not look at me.

Edwin looked from the fabric in my hands to the fabric on Norma.

“Norma’s robe?” he asked.

Nadine nodded quickly.

“It was passed down in our family.”

“By whom?”

“Irene.”

“To Norma?”

The question was quiet.

Nadine hesitated less than a second.

“Yes.”

My father stared at her.

That was the first crack I saw in him all night.

He had believed Nadine’s letter. He had believed her warnings about my grief.

But even he knew my mother had never given Norma that robe.

Nadine noticed his expression.

“Irene intended it for the girl who continued her musical legacy,” she added.

“You mean the girl you chose,” I said.

“Audrey, please don’t start again.”

Edwin’s hand tightened around the key.

“She was outside in the snow with a bleeding hand,” he said. “I believe something had already started.”

No one spoke.

From the sanctuary, the organist played a soft chord, then stopped. Beyond the choir doors, hundreds of people waited in the pews.

Edwin turned to Mrs. Keller.

“Bring me a choir blanket and the first-aid box.”

Mrs. Keller hurried away.

Nadine moved closer to him.

“Edwin, the service is already delayed.”

He looked at her.

At eighty-four, Edwin Aldridge did not need to raise his voice. His silence did the work for him.

Nadine’s smile tightened.

“I only mean that we have a responsibility to the congregation.”

“We also have a responsibility to the truth.”

Norma’s head lifted.

For one second, fear crossed her face.

Then Nadine touched her back.

“Go stand by the sanctuary doors,” she whispered.

Norma obeyed.

Mrs. Keller returned with a navy wool blanket and a white metal box.

Edwin took the blanket himself.

“Your coat is wet,” he told me. “Let me have it.”

His voice was gentler now.

I handed back his coat, and he wrapped the blanket around my shoulders. Then he led me to a wooden bench beneath a carved angel.

My teeth had begun to chatter.

Mrs. Keller knelt and cleaned my palm.

The antiseptic stung.

I did not make a sound.

Nadine watched as if waiting for me to scream.

Edwin sat beside me.

“May I see the fabric?”

I looked down at the piece of robe clutched beneath the blanket.

The red thread still hung from the torn cross.

I wanted to say no.

The robe was the last thing of my mother’s that Nadine had not hidden, sold, or thrown away. Letting anyone touch it felt dangerous.

But Edwin had opened the door.

I placed the fabric in his hands.

He handled it as though it were something alive.

His thumb moved over the gold trim, then stopped at the crooked cross.

The pattern was simple at first glance. Four narrow arms met at the center, outlined in faded silver thread. One arm tilted slightly upward.

The red thread ran through the middle.

Edwin’s eyes closed.

“You know it,” I said.

He opened them.

“I know the pattern.”

“How?”

His gaze moved to the little pendant resting outside my torn blouse.

The silver cross my mother had given me was shaped almost exactly like the stitched one.

One short arm.

One crooked line.

One narrow stripe of red.

Edwin touched neither of them.

Instead, he turned the torn cloth toward the light.

“I designed this pattern many years ago,” he said.

Nadine went still.

“For the cathedral?” I asked.

“For one singer.”

“My mother?”

He looked at me for a long moment.

“Yes.”

The word nearly broke inside him.

Behind us, the sanctuary doors opened a few inches.

Candlelight moved across the vestibule. I saw rows of faces turning toward the delay.

Nadine stepped between us.

“That doesn’t mean Audrey owns the robe.”

Edwin did not look up.

“It means you were wrong when you called it Norma’s.”

“I said it belongs to our family.”

Up next