Part 2 of 9

“Who taught you that unfinished song?” Locked outside in Christmas snow with a bleeding palm, I sang—then the choir director saw my silver cross.

36 min read · November 16, 2026

“You said Irene passed it to Norma.”

“She would have.”

“You cannot ask a dead woman to support your version of events.”

A choir member gasped.

Nadine’s eyes hardened.

Then she remembered the audience.

Her face softened at once.

“I’m trying to protect both girls,” she said. “Norma earned this opportunity. Audrey simply cannot accept that.”

She reached into her handbag and withdrew a cream-colored envelope.

“There is the invitation.”

She held it up so everyone could see Norma Whitaker written across the front.

A dark blue seal marked the flap.

My stomach dropped.

It looked real.

Not like the envelope I had seen earlier with my own name.

This one had Norma’s.

Nadine opened it and unfolded a thick sheet of paper.

“Dear Miss Norma Whitaker,” she read. “The scholarship committee of St. Mercy Cathedral is pleased to invite you to perform as our Christmas Eve candidate.”

She lowered the page.

“It is signed by Mr. Aldridge himself.”

Every eye turned toward Edwin.

He held out his hand.

Nadine did not give him the letter.

“Surely you remember signing it.”

“I remember every invitation I prepare.”

Something flickered across her face.

She passed it to him.

Edwin read the letter once.

Then again.

His expression did not change, but his thumb paused beneath the signature.

I leaned closer.

The name at the bottom looked like his.

Edwin Aldridge.

The letters were graceful and dark, with a long sweep under the last name.

Edwin turned the page toward the light.

He studied the seal.

Then he folded the letter carefully and returned it.

“Mrs. Keller,” Nadine said, “you were in the office when Norma’s invitation was processed.”

Mrs. Keller had just finished wrapping my palm. Her hands froze around the bandage.

“I helped with the Christmas mailings,” she said.

“And you saw Norma’s name on the list.”

Mrs. Keller glanced at Edwin.

“I saw the invitation Nadine brought to the office.”

“That isn’t what I asked.”

Nadine’s voice remained pleasant, but a warning moved beneath it.

Mrs. Keller swallowed.

“Audrey’s name was not on the copy I saw.”

My chest tightened.

“Because Nadine took mine.”

“Oh, honestly,” Nadine said. “How could I take something that never existed?”

“It was in my room.”

“You told us no invitation came,” my father said.

Everyone turned toward him.

He looked confused, almost frightened by his own voice.

Nadine stared at him.

“I said no invitation came for Audrey.”

“You said the cathedral hadn’t made a decision.”

“I was trying to spare her feelings.”

“By letting her come here tonight?”

“I didn’t know she would force her way into Norma’s audition.”

“I didn’t force my way in,” I said. “She forced me out.”

Nadine ignored me.

She took my father’s arm.

“David, you know how Audrey has been. The accusations. The fixation on Irene’s things. Singing songs no one else has heard.”

Edwin looked sharply at me.

“The song,” he said.

The room quieted.

He placed the torn robe across his knees.

“Who taught you that unfinished song?”

Nadine opened her mouth.

Edwin raised one finger.

“I asked Audrey.”

My throat tightened.

No one had ever called it unfinished except my mother and me.

Not even Norma should have known that.

“My mother taught me,” I said.

“From written music?”

“No.”

“Then how?”

I looked toward the sanctuary.

The organist waited at the bench. Candles burned beside the altar. Norma stood beneath the lights in my mother’s torn robe.

“She sang it at home.”

“When?”

“All the time.”

The memories came so quickly they hurt.

“When she cooked. When she folded laundry. When she brushed my hair.”

My voice weakened.

“She hummed it when storms kept me awake. Sometimes she sang it while sewing at the kitchen table. She never sat me down and taught it like a lesson. I just heard it for years.”

“Did she ever sing it here?”

“I don’t know.”

“Did she give you the music?”

“No. Nadine took her songbooks after she died.”

“I put them away,” Nadine said.

“Where?”

“They’re family property.”

“They were my mother’s.”

Edwin held my gaze.

“How did the song end?”

“It didn’t.”

“What do you mean?”

“She always stopped before the final line.”

The choir shifted behind him.

Edwin’s voice fell almost to a whisper.

“At the same place you stopped outside?”

“Yes.”

His hand moved toward the silver tuning fork in his vest, but he did not take it out.

“Why did she stop?”

“I don’t know.”

That was the truth.

It was also the question I had carried for years.

Sometimes I believed Mom stopped because she had forgotten the words.

Sometimes I feared the ending belonged to the future she had lost when she had me.

Nadine had fed that fear until it became part of me.

Your mother chose a child instead of music.

Your mother gave up.

Your mother left you nothing.

Edwin studied my face.

“Sing the last phrase you remember.”

My mouth went dry.

“Here?”

“Here.”

Nadine laughed softly.

“This is absurd. She heard Norma rehearsing and memorized part of the song.”

Norma finally looked at me.

We both knew that was impossible.

I had sung the melody to myself years before Nadine married my father. Once, Norma had caught me humming it in the backyard.

She had asked what it was.

Up next