Part 4 of 9

“Who taught you that unfinished song?” Locked outside in Christmas snow with a bleeding palm, I sang—then the choir director saw my silver cross.

36 min read · November 16, 2026

From there, I could barely see the altar.

I could see Edwin.

He stood near the side door with his eyes fixed on the invitation in Nadine’s hand.

Then he looked down at the torn cross I held against my heart.

Norma began my mother’s song again.

The congregation listened.

And I stood hidden at the back of the choir while everyone applauded the wrong girl.

Chapter 3

Norma sang my mother’s melody beneath the sanctuary lights.

From the last row, I watched her miss every place where the song was supposed to ache.

The congregation did not notice.

They saw a pretty eighteen-year-old in a red-and-gold robe, singing bravely after what Nadine had already described as a “family disturbance.”

They saw Nadine in the front pew, one hand pressed to her heart.

They did not see the way she glanced back to make sure I stayed hidden.

I held the torn half of the robe beneath the choir blanket.

The red thread curled around my finger.

Edwin stood beside the organ, but he was not following the music.

He was watching Nadine.

More precisely, he was watching the invitation in her hand.

When Norma reached the unfinished turn in the melody, she took the easier note.

Edwin’s jaw tightened.

My mother had always climbed there.

Even when she sang softly beside my bed, her voice rose as though it could carry both of us somewhere safer.

Norma finished to warm applause.

Nadine stood first.

She turned toward the congregation, smiling through tears that had not been there a moment earlier.

Then she looked back at me.

Her eyes were dry.

The organ began an interlude while the choir moved into position for the closing hymn.

My father appeared at the side aisle carrying my overnight bag.

For one foolish second, hope lifted inside me.

He had gone to the car.

He had brought my proof.

He walked toward the last row, but Nadine intercepted him before he reached me.

“What are you doing?” she whispered.

“Audrey said her confirmation was in here.”

“We are not digging through her things in the middle of a service.”

“We should have checked before.”

Nadine’s fingers closed around the bag.

“You saw the invitation.”

“I saw the one you showed me.”

“It has Norma’s name on it.”

“Yes.”

His voice dropped.

“But the first envelope had Audrey’s.”

Nadine went completely still.

So did I.

My father remembered.

In the vestibule, before she replaced it with the letter bearing Norma’s name, Nadine had held up an envelope with mine.

She had counted on his confusion.

She had counted on his silence.

She had counted correctly for most of the night.

“David,” she said, “you’re upset.”

“I know what I saw.”

“You saw Audrey’s forgery.”

“Then why did you have it?”

Nadine’s face tightened.

The organ covered their voices, but Mrs. Keller was close enough to hear. She busied herself straightening hymnals.

Nadine smiled at my father.

It was the smile she used just before punishing someone in private.

“We will discuss this at home.”

She tried to take the bag.

He held on.

“No.”

One word.

Weak and late, but it was the first one he had given her.

He stepped around Nadine and brought the bag to me.

“I’m sorry,” he whispered.

I did not say it was all right.

It wasn’t.

He had watched her call me unstable.

He had watched her tear the robe.

He had told me to go home.

Sorry could not warm the snow out of my bones.

I took the bag anyway.

“The email is in the front pocket.”

He unzipped it and found the folded page.

Before he could open it, Nadine caught his wrist.

“Not here.”

Edwin appeared beside us.

“Yes,” he said. “Here.”

Nadine released my father.

Edwin took the printed email and read it beneath the small choir lamp.

I watched his eyes move across the page.

The confirmation had arrived four weeks earlier.

Dear Audrey Whitaker.

Christmas Eve scholarship audition.

Arrival time, rehearsal instructions, committee contact.

At the bottom was Edwin’s name.

This signature was short and plain.

Nothing like the graceful, sweeping signature on Norma’s letter.

Edwin folded the email.

“Where did you get this?”

“It came to my account.”

“Did anyone else have access?”

“My father did.”

Nadine answered before he could.

“So did Audrey. She could have made it herself.”

Edwin looked at her.

“The cathedral’s internal reference number is printed here.”

Her smile flickered.

“That could have been copied.”

“From where?”

“She is very resourceful.”

Edwin took Norma’s invitation from Nadine.

He placed both pages side by side.

The differences were obvious once I knew to look.

The seal on my email showed St. Mercy’s bell between two narrow wings.

The seal on Norma’s letter showed the bell, but the wings were wider and the date beneath them was missing.

My page carried Edwin’s initials in a block beneath his name.

Norma’s did not.

And the signatures were nothing alike.

“You didn’t sign hers,” I said.

Edwin’s eyes stayed on the papers.

“No.”

Nadine drew in a breath.

“It came from the cathedral office.”

“No invitation leaves my office without my initials.”

“Then someone made a clerical error.”

“Someone made several.”

His voice remained quiet, but Mrs. Keller turned pale.

Up next