Part 5 of 9

“Who taught you that unfinished song?” Locked outside in Christmas snow with a bleeding palm, I sang—then the choir director saw my silver cross.

36 min read · November 16, 2026

Nadine noticed.

“Mrs. Keller already confirmed that Audrey’s name wasn’t on the list.”

“I confirmed what I saw,” Mrs. Keller said.

“You saw Norma’s invitation.”

“I saw the copy you brought me.”

The organ interlude ended.

The choirmaster’s assistant motioned frantically toward Edwin.

The congregation was waiting again.

Nadine took advantage of the movement.

She leaned close to me.

“Give me the bag and the robe.”

“No.”

Her public smile remained in place.

“Do not make this worse.”

“You forged that letter.”

“Be very careful what you accuse me of.”

“You stole mine.”

“Hand over the robe.”

“It was my mother’s.”

“And the songbook.”

My hand tightened around the bag.

Nadine saw it.

Her eyes sharpened.

“So you do have it.”

I had saved one book.

The night Nadine packed my mother’s music into basement boxes, I had found a thin red volume beneath the piano bench. I slipped it inside the torn lining of my overnight bag.

For two years, Nadine had never discovered it.

Until now.

She reached for the zipper.

I pulled the bag against my chest.

“You told everyone you put her songbooks away.”

“I did.”

“You mean you hid them.”

“They belong to the family.”

“You keep saying that when you mean they belong to you.”

Her fingers dug into my arm.

“If you refuse to give those things to me, I will tell the scholarship committee you are having another episode.”

“Another?”

“You wandered outside without a coat. You cut yourself. You interrupted the service.”

“You pushed me into the snow.”

“Who saw that?”

The question brought back the locked door.

Her satisfied face.

They’ll believe me.

“Nadine,” my father said.

She did not release me.

“She needs help, David. You know that.”

“No,” he said. “I know she needs you to let go of her.”

Nadine stared at him.

Edwin stepped between us.

“Mrs. Whitaker, return to your seat.”

“This is a family matter.”

“You brought it into my cathedral.”

For an instant, her face emptied of every pleasant expression.

“You are an old man who heard half a song through a door.”

Edwin did not move.

“And you are delaying Christmas Eve over a dead woman’s dress.”

The words struck me so hard I stopped breathing.

Edwin’s face changed.

Not with anger.

With grief.

He took the silver tuning fork from his vest pocket and held it tightly, as if the cool metal steadied his hand.

Then he looked at me.

“Bring the robe and the book.”

He led me through a narrow door behind the choir stalls.

My father followed.

Nadine tried to come with us, but Edwin shut the door in her face.

The small room beyond held spare hymnals, candles, and old choir photographs.

I placed my overnight bag on a table and pulled back the torn lining.

The red songbook slid into my hands.

Edwin recognized it immediately.

“Irene’s.”

I nodded.

He opened the cover.

My mother’s handwriting filled the first page.

Irene Marie Whitaker.

Beneath it, written years later in softer pencil, were three more words.

For my Audrey.

My father made a broken sound.

I touched the words.

“I never saw that.”

“You weren’t meant to yet,” Edwin said.

He turned the pages slowly.

Breathing exercises.

Latin hymns.

Notes from rehearsals.

Then he found the unfinished song.

The melody covered three pages in my mother’s careful hand.

The final measure was blank.

Below it, she had written:

The last line is not mine to sing.

I stared at the sentence.

“What does that mean?”

Edwin lowered himself into a chair.

For the first time that night, he looked eighty-four.

“The year Irene turned seventeen, St. Mercy offered her the same scholarship you were invited to receive.”

“Nadine said she abandoned it.”

“She surrendered it.”

“Isn’t that the same thing?”

“No.”

His answer came sharply.

“Abandonment is walking away because something has no value. Irene knew exactly what it was worth.”

He looked toward my father.

“You and Irene were barely more than children. When she learned she was expecting Audrey, people told her to leave school, leave the choir, and be grateful for whatever life remained.”

My father sat against the wall.

“She never told me they said that.”

“She did not want pity.”

Edwin turned another page.

“She intended to audition anyway. She wrote this song for it. But the scholarship required months of travel and residency. There was no provision for an infant. No family housing. No place for a young mother.”

“So she chose me.”

The old guilt returned before I could stop it.

Because of me.

She had lost the cathedral, the scholarship, and the future her voice might have given her.

Edwin must have seen it on my face.

“Do not turn her love into a crime against yourself.”

My eyes burned.

“She could have had this.”

“Yes.”

“But she gave it up because I was born.”

“She gave up one road because she refused to give you up.”

He tapped the open songbook.

“That is not the same as wishing you had never existed.”

I looked down at the unfinished measure.

“Why didn’t she finish the song?”

“She did not want to finish it without you.”

I looked at him.

Edwin’s voice softened.

Up next