Part 4 of 9

“Your mother isn’t here to help you now.” My stepmother shoved me toward a stage edge, then my father saw what was inside my cracked processor.

38 min read · November 15, 2026

Ruth looked at Dad.

Dad looked at me.

I could not hear the question he asked, but I read his lips.

Do you want to go home?

I looked at the Christmas lights.

At the manger.

At the solo card lying face down on the floor.

At Peggy, who had stolen my song because her mother promised applause.

And at the open battery door where Mom’s words waited, unfinished.

I shook my head.

Not home.

Not yet.

Geraldine raised one hand toward the pianist.

“Begin.”

The first notes of the angel solo filled the church.

Peggy lifted her face toward the congregation.

Then she began to sing the song that had been written for me.

Chapter 3

Peggy lifted her face toward the congregation.

Then she began to sing the song that had been written for me.

I could see her mouth forming the words.

I could see the pianist’s fingers moving.

I could see Ruth watching me from beside the choir.

But I could not hear the music.

I could not hear Peggy’s voice.

The church had become a silent picture show, and I was trapped inside it.

Peggy sang the first verse with her hands pressed against the sides of her white dress. Her voice looked steady. Geraldine stood behind her, smiling at the congregation as if she had planned every beautiful moment.

Maybe she had.

Dad remained beside me, holding my cracked processor in one hand.

The battery door hung open.

Mom’s unfinished message was hidden inside.

I kept looking at the words, even though I could not read them from where I stood.

Peggy’s name was there.

That was enough to make my chest ache.

Geraldine glanced at me.

Then she leaned toward Dad.

“Shirley is making this very difficult,” she said.

I could not hear her, but I read the shape of my own name.

Dad turned toward her.

“What did you say?”

Geraldine gave him a sorrowful look.

“I said she needs to calm down.”

Dad’s jaw tightened.

“She needs her processor.”

“And she needs to stop demanding attention during Peggy’s solo.”

I looked at him.

Dad looked at me, then toward the stage.

“Peggy’s solo was Shirley’s.”

Geraldine’s smile stayed in place.

“Not anymore.”

That was the first time she said it plainly.

Not Shirley was confused.

Not Shirley had failed.

Not there had been a mistake.

Not anymore.

She had decided it.

She had taken my song and handed it to Peggy.

The truth should have made me feel stronger.

Instead, it made my legs feel weak.

Geraldine had not been trying to protect the pageant.

She had been trying to erase me from it.

Ruth stepped away from the choir and came toward us.

She carried a folder against her chest.

Her face was tight with anger.

“Wesley,” she said, “I need to show you something.”

Geraldine moved between them.

“Ruth, please. The children are performing.”

“The children are performing a part you changed without permission.”

Geraldine’s eyebrows lifted.

“I changed nothing.”

Ruth opened the folder.

“I have the original rehearsal program.”

Geraldine’s eyes darted to the pages.

I saw it happen.

A quick flicker.

A warning.

Then the church smile returned.

“Ruth, this is not the time.”

“It is exactly the time.”

Ruth pulled out a stapled sheet and handed it to Dad.

He took it without looking away from Geraldine.

“What is this?” he asked.

“The copy I used during every rehearsal.”

Dad lowered his eyes.

The page trembled slightly in his hand.

At the top, beneath the title Christmas at Bethlehem, were the names of the children and their parts.

He read silently.

Then his gaze stopped.

Ruth pointed to the bottom half of the page.

“Read it aloud.”

Geraldine shook her head.

“Wesley, don’t let this become a spectacle.”

Dad ignored her.

His voice came slowly.

“Angel solo… Shirley Lockhart.”

Ruth nodded.

“Signed and dated three weeks ago.”

Dad looked at the bottom.

Ruth had written her initials beside the assignment.

Geraldine reached for the program.

Dad pulled it away.

“Why is Peggy’s name on the card?”

Geraldine folded her arms.

“Because Peggy learned the song.”

“So did Shirley.”

“Shirley’s condition makes things unpredictable.”

“There was nothing unpredictable in the rehearsal assignment.”

“Things changed.”

“When?”

Geraldine glanced at the stage.

Peggy was halfway through the second verse.

Her eyes were fixed on the back wall, not on the congregation. Every few seconds, she looked toward Geraldine.

Geraldine gave her a small nod each time.

“During rehearsal,” she said.

Ruth’s voice sharpened.

“I never changed it.”

“Perhaps you forgot.”

“I did not.”

“You are tired, Ruth. We all are.”

Ruth turned to Dad.

“She changed the cards before the pageant began. I watched her go behind the curtain with Shirley’s folder.”

Geraldine laughed softly.

“That is a serious accusation.”

“It is a fact.”

“Did you see me write Peggy’s name?”

“I saw you holding a marker.”

“I was labeling the costume bins.”

“You were standing over the solo cards.”

“I was organizing.”

“You also took the spare battery from Shirley’s coat.”

Geraldine’s face hardened.

“I was trying to prevent another disruption.”

Dad looked at the small plastic battery case still sticking out of Geraldine’s pocket.

“You took it.”

Geraldine touched the pocket instinctively.

Then she dropped her hand.

“I took it because Shirley had been misplacing things.”

“You hid it.”

“I kept it somewhere safe.”

“You kept it from her.”

“She did not need it.”

Dad stared at her.

“How would you know?”

“Because she was fine during rehearsal.”

Ruth stepped closer.

“Her processor was warning her before the pageant even started.”

Up next