Part 5 of 9

“Your mother isn’t here to help you now.” My stepmother shoved me toward a stage edge, then my father saw what was inside my cracked processor.

38 min read · November 15, 2026

Geraldine looked at me.

“She said it was fine.”

I shook my head.

“I said I needed the battery.”

“You were upset.”

“I told you.”

“You were looking for attention.”

Dad’s expression changed.

“Enough.”

Geraldine turned toward him.

“Wesley, she cannot hear the accompaniment. You know that.”

“She can sing by watching Ruth.”

“She missed the signal tonight.”

“Because you blocked her view.”

Geraldine’s mouth opened.

For once, no answer came out quickly.

Ruth looked at the congregation.

Several people had risen from their seats. A few of the children were staring at Geraldine instead of Peggy. The adults had stopped pretending this was a normal pageant interruption.

The piano continued.

Peggy began the final verse.

Her voice moved silently across her face.

I had practiced that verse until I could sing it in my sleep.

It was the part where the angel tells the shepherds not to be afraid.

I had imagined singing it while looking at Dad.

I had imagined finding Mom in the words.

Now Peggy was singing it while Geraldine watched me fall apart.

The final note ended.

The congregation applauded.

I saw hands coming together.

I saw mouths open in praise.

I saw Geraldine bow her head modestly.

Peggy did not bow.

She stood frozen beneath the microphone.

Her eyes found mine.

I could not hear the applause, but I knew what it meant.

Everyone thought she had won.

Geraldine turned to the congregation.

“Thank you,” she said. “Peggy stepped in at the last moment because Shirley was unable to continue.”

My fingers closed around the edge of Dad’s sleeve.

Ruth’s face flushed.

“She did not step in at the last moment.”

Geraldine raised her voice.

“Ruth, please.”

“She took Shirley’s assigned part.”

“She performed the part she had practiced.”

“After you changed the cards.”

Geraldine turned toward Dad.

“Are you really going to let this happen?”

Dad looked at the program.

Then at the card on the floor.

Then at me.

“I’m trying to understand.”

“You understand perfectly,” Geraldine said. “Shirley is upset because she cannot accept that Peggy was chosen.”

“I chose Shirley.”

Ruth’s words were quiet.

Everyone heard them.

“I chose Shirley,” she repeated. “And I never changed my mind.”

Geraldine’s face reddened.

“Then perhaps you should have considered the needs of the whole group.”

“Shirley is part of the whole group.”

“She cannot hear the music.”

“She can read the signals.”

“She could not tonight.”

“Because her processor was damaged.”

“Because she dropped it.”

“Because Peggy stomped on it,” I said.

My voice came out too loud.

Several people turned.

Peggy looked down.

Geraldine walked toward her.

“Peggy,” she said, “tell them what happened.”

Peggy’s shoulders rose.

Geraldine’s expression softened in the way it did when adults were watching.

“Tell them Shirley dropped the device.”

Peggy’s lips parted.

I waited.

Dad waited.

Ruth waited.

The church waited.

Peggy glanced at the open battery door in Dad’s hand.

Then at Geraldine.

“She dropped it,” Peggy said.

The lie was soft.

It still cut.

Geraldine turned back to the congregation.

“There. Peggy has told you what happened.”

Ruth shook her head.

“Peggy is frightened.”

Geraldine’s eyes narrowed.

“Do not accuse my daughter of lying.”

“She is ten.”

“So is Shirley.”

The words hung between them.

Geraldine had meant them as a defense.

Instead, they made the truth sharper.

Both girls were ten.

Both girls stood beneath the same Christmas lights.

But one of us had been allowed to make a mistake.

The other had been used as the mistake.

Dad looked at Peggy.

“Did Geraldine tell you to stomp on Shirley’s processor?”

Peggy’s face crumpled.

Geraldine stepped in front of her.

“Wesley, stop questioning her.”

“I asked Peggy.”

“She is overwhelmed.”

“Peggy.”

Peggy looked at Dad.

For one second, I believed she might tell him.

Her mouth trembled.

Her eyes filled.

Then Geraldine reached behind her and took hold of the gold angel clip in Peggy’s hair.

She did not pull it.

She only touched it.

But Peggy went rigid.

Geraldine smiled at Dad.

“She needs a moment.”

Dad looked at the clip.

Then at Geraldine’s hand.

“Take your hand off her.”

Geraldine slowly lowered it.

“Why are you treating me like a criminal?”

“Because you keep lying.”

The congregation reacted with a murmur.

Geraldine’s face changed.

She had expected Dad to defend her.

He had done it before.

When I told him she hid my batteries, she said I had forgotten where I put them.

When I said my rehearsal notes were missing, she said I had left them at school.

When I said Geraldine stood in front of Ruth during practice, she said I was being sensitive.

Dad had accepted every explanation.

Tonight, the explanations were standing under the microphone with a cracked device in his hand.

Geraldine looked around the church.

“This is my family,” she said. “I will not be humiliated in front of these people.”

“You humiliated Shirley in front of them.”

“She was not supposed to be singing.”

“Why not?”

“Because she cannot do it reliably.”

There it was.

The sentence she had been hiding behind all evening.

Not the pageant.

Not the children.

Not a mistake.

Me.

Dad’s face went pale.

“You told everyone she was unreliable.”

“She is.”

Ruth took the program from Dad and held it up.

“Then why did you wait until tonight to replace her?”

Geraldine said nothing.

Ruth turned toward the congregation.

“Shirley attended every rehearsal. She learned every entrance. She practiced with the choir, with the piano, and with the hand signals I gave her.”

Geraldine cut in.

“And she still could not hear the music.”

Up next